School of Biomedical Sciences, Faculty of Health, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.
Department of Physiology, School of Biomedical Sciences, Monash University, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Adv Physiol Educ. 2023 Sep 1;47(3):443-452. doi: 10.1152/advan.00145.2022. Epub 2023 May 18.
An Australia-wide consensus was reached on seven core concepts of physiology, one of which was cell-cell communication. Three physiology educators from a "core concepts" Delphi task force "unpacked" this core concept into seven different themes and 60 subthemes. Cell-cell communication, previously unpacked and validated, was modified for an Australian audience to include emerging knowledge and adapted to increase student accessibility. The unpacked hierarchical framework for this core concept was rated by 24 physiology educators from separate Australian universities, using a five-point scale for level of importance for student understanding (ranging from 1 = Essential to 5 = Not Important) and level of difficulty (ranging from 1 = Very Difficult to 5 = Not Difficult). Data were analyzed with the Kruskal-Wallis test with Dunn's multiple comparison test. The seven themes were rated within a narrow range of importance (1.13-2.4), with ratings of Essential or Important, and statistically significant differences between the themes ( < 0.0001, = 7). The variance for the difficulty rating was higher than for importance, ranging from 2.15 (Difficult) to 3.45 (between Moderately Difficult and Slightly Difficult). Qualitatively, it was suggested that some subthemes were similar and that these could be grouped. However, all themes and subthemes were ranked as Important, validating this framework. Once finalized and adopted across Australian universities, the unpacked core concept for cell-cell communication will enable the generation of tools and resources for physiology educators and improvements in consistency across curricula. Seven core concepts, including cell-cell communication, were identified by an Australian Delphi task force of physiology educators. The previously "unpacked" concept was adapted for Australian educators and students to develop a framework with seven themes and 60 subthemes. The framework was successfully validated by the original Delphi panel of educators and will provide a valuable resource for teaching and learning in Australian universities.
澳大利亚范围内就生理学的七个核心概念达成共识,其中之一是细胞间通讯。来自“核心概念”德尔菲工作组的三位生理学教育工作者将这一核心概念“分解”为七个不同的主题和 60 个子主题。细胞间通讯之前已经被“分解”并得到验证,为了澳大利亚受众,它被修改为纳入新的知识,并适应于提高学生的可理解性。该核心概念的“分解”层次框架由来自澳大利亚不同大学的 24 名生理学教育工作者进行了评估,他们使用五分制来评估对学生理解的重要程度(范围从 1=必不可少到 5=不重要)和难度(范围从 1=非常难到 5=不难)。使用 Kruskal-Wallis 检验和 Dunn 多重比较检验对数据进行了分析。这七个主题的重要性评分范围很窄(1.13-2.4),均为必不可少或重要,并且主题之间存在统计学差异(<0.0001,=7)。难度评分的方差高于重要性评分,范围从 2.15(困难)到 3.45(介于较难和稍难之间)。从定性上看,一些子主题是相似的,可以将它们进行分组。然而,所有的主题和子主题都被评为重要,验证了这个框架。一旦在澳大利亚的大学中最终确定并采用,这个细胞间通讯的“分解”核心概念将使生理学教育工作者能够生成工具和资源,并提高课程之间的一致性。七个核心概念,包括细胞间通讯,是由澳大利亚的一个生理学教育工作者德尔菲工作组确定的。之前“分解”的概念是为澳大利亚教育工作者和学生改编的,以制定一个包含七个主题和 60 个子主题的框架。该框架得到了最初的德尔菲小组教育工作者的成功验证,将为澳大利亚大学的教学和学习提供有价值的资源。