Faculty of Health Sciences and Medicine, Bond University, Gold Coast, Australia.
School of Health Sciences, College of Health and Medicine, University of Tasmania, Newnham, Australia.
Adv Physiol Educ. 2023 Sep 1;47(3):436-442. doi: 10.1152/advan.00144.2022. Epub 2023 May 25.
Consensus was reached on seven core concepts of physiology using the Delphi method, including "integration," outlined by the descriptor "cells, tissues, organs, and organ systems interact to create and sustain life." This core concept was unpacked by a team of 3 Australian physiology educators into hierarchical levels, identifying 5 themes and 10 subthemes, up to 1 level deep. The unpacked core concept was then circulated among 23 experienced physiology educators for comments and to rate both level of importance and level of difficulty for each theme and subtheme. Data were analyzed using a one-way ANOVA to compare between and within themes. The main theme () was almost universally rated as Essential. Interestingly, the main theme was also rated between Slightly Difficult to Not Difficult, which was significantly different from all other subthemes. There were two separate subsets of themes in relation to importance, with three themes rating between Essential and Important and the two other themes rating as Important. Two subsets in the difficulty of the main themes were also identified. While many core concepts can be taught concurrently, Integration requires the application of prior knowledge, with the expectation that learners should be able to apply concepts from "cell-cell communication," "homeostasis," and "structure and function," before understanding the overall Integration core concept. As such, themes from the Integration core concept should be taught within the endmost semesters of a Physiology program. This article proposes the inclusion of a core concept regarding "integration" into physiology-based curricula, with the descriptor "cells, tissues, organs, and organ systems interact to create and sustain life." This concept expands prior knowledge and applies physiological understanding to real-world scenarios and introduces contexts such as medications, diseases, and aging to the student learning experience. To comprehend the topics within the Integration core concept, students will need to apply learned material from earlier semesters.
使用德尔菲法就生理学的七个核心概念达成了共识,其中包括“整合”,其描述为“细胞、组织、器官和器官系统相互作用以创造和维持生命”。澳大利亚的 3 位生理学教育工作者团队对这一核心概念进行了深入剖析,确定了 5 个主题和 10 个子主题,最多可深入到第 1 级。随后,该未拆封的核心概念被分发给 23 名经验丰富的生理学教育工作者征求意见,并对每个主题和子主题的重要性和难度进行评级。使用单向方差分析对主题之间和主题内的数据进行分析。主要主题()几乎被普遍认为是必不可少的。有趣的是,主要主题的难度评级也介于稍微困难到不困难之间,这与所有其他子主题明显不同。与重要性相关的主题有两个独立的子集,其中三个主题的评级介于必要和重要之间,另外两个主题的评级为重要。主要主题的难度也有两个子集。虽然许多核心概念可以同时教授,但整合需要应用先验知识,期望学习者在理解整体整合核心概念之前,应该能够应用“细胞间通讯”、“稳态”和“结构与功能”等概念。因此,整合核心概念的主题应该在生理学课程的最后几个学期教授。本文提出在基于生理学的课程中纳入一个关于“整合”的核心概念,描述为“细胞、组织、器官和器官系统相互作用以创造和维持生命”。这个概念扩展了先验知识,并将生理学理解应用于现实世界的场景,并向学生学习体验中引入了药物、疾病和衰老等背景。为了理解整合核心概念中的主题,学生将需要从早期学期应用所学材料。