Storm Rasmus K, Nesseler Cornel, Holum Marthe, Nygaard Andreas, Jakobsen Tor Georg
Danish Institute for Sports Studies, Aarhus, Denmark.
Present Address: NTNU Business School, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway.
Humanit Soc Sci Commun. 2023;10(1):230. doi: 10.1057/s41599-023-01734-7. Epub 2023 May 11.
In this paper, we examine ethnic discrimination using sport as a laboratory. Applying a field experiment in the three Scandinavian countries-Sweden, Norway, and Denmark-we test whether foreign female minority groups experience greater rejection rates when seeking inclusion in amateur soccer clubs. Soccer coaches were contacted by e-mail using native and foreign-sounding names from selected groups, requesting to participate in trial practice. Previous findings show persistent discrimination of foreign minority groups in the labour market, and recent work suggests that discrimination also occurs in the context of soccer. Our findings from Scandinavia show that Sweden is the only country that shows statistically significant signs of discriminatory patterns, and the probability of experiencing discrimination increases with cultural distance. However, cultural distance appears to have no influence in Norway and Denmark. We further investigate whether male or female coaches demonstrate different discriminatory behaviour when being contacted, but our analysis shows almost no gender differences. Findings suggest that how men and women differ in their discriminatory behaviour is context specific. The differences identified across nations and previous studies are discussed to better understand the mechanisms of discrimination.
在本文中,我们将体育作为一个实验室来研究种族歧视问题。通过在瑞典、挪威和丹麦这三个斯堪的纳维亚国家开展一项实地实验,我们测试了外国女性少数群体在寻求加入业余足球俱乐部时是否会遭遇更高的拒绝率。我们通过电子邮件联系足球教练,使用选定群体中听起来像本地人或外国人的名字,请求参加试训。此前的研究结果表明,外国少数群体在劳动力市场中持续遭受歧视,而近期的研究表明,足球领域也存在歧视现象。我们在斯堪的纳维亚地区的研究结果显示,瑞典是唯一呈现出具有统计学显著意义的歧视模式迹象的国家,且遭受歧视的概率会随着文化距离的增加而上升。然而,文化距离在挪威和丹麦似乎并无影响。我们进一步调查了男性教练和女性教练在被联系时是否表现出不同的歧视行为,但我们的分析显示几乎不存在性别差异。研究结果表明,男性和女性在歧视行为上的差异是因具体情境而异的。我们讨论了在不同国家以及此前研究中发现的差异,以便更好地理解歧视的机制。