Kottler Janey, Gingell Monica J, Khosla Shaveta, Kordzikowski Mitchell, Raszewski Rebecca, Chestek David, Maki Katherine A
Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Illinois Hospital & Health Sciences System, Chicago, IL, 60612.
College of Nursing, University of Illinois Chicago, Chicago, IL, 60612.
medRxiv. 2023 Apr 19:2023.04.16.23288657. doi: 10.1101/2023.04.16.23288657.
The COVID-19 pandemic has strained the mental and physical well-being of healthcare workers (HCW). Increased work-related stress and limited resources has increased symptoms of anxiety, depression, insomnia, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in this population. Stress-related disorders have been strongly associated with long-term consequences including cardiometabolic disorders, endocrine disorders and premature mortality. This scoping review aims to explore available literature on burnout, PTSD, and other mental health-associated symptoms in HCW to synthesize relationships with physiological and biological biomarkers that may be associated with increased risk of disease, creating an opportunity to summarize current biomarker knowledge and identify gaps in this literature.
This scoping review uses the Arksey and O'Malley six-step scoping review methodology framework. The research team will select appropriate primary sources using a search strategy developed in collaboration with a health sciences librarian. Three reviewers will initially screen the title and abstracts obtained from the literature searches, and two reviewers will conduct independent reviews of full-text studies for inclusion. The research team will be reviewing literature focusing on which burnout and/or PTSD-associated physiological and biological biomarkers have been studied, the methodologies used to study them and the correlations between the biomarkers and HCW experiencing burnout/PTSD. Data extraction forms will be completed by two reviewers for included studies and will guide literature synthesis and analysis to determine common themes.
This review does not require ethical approval. We expect results from this scoping review to identify gaps in the literature and encourage future research regarding improving biologic and physiologic biomarker research in HCW. Preliminary results and general themes will be communicated back to stakeholders. Results will be disseminated through peer-reviewed publications, policy briefs, and conferences, as well as presented to stakeholders to an effort to invest in HCW mental and physical health.
This will be the first scoping review to assess the current understanding of the biologic and physiological impact of burnout on healthcare workers. The target population is restricted to healthcare workers; however, identified research gaps may be used to guide future studies in other high-burnout occupations and industries.This scoping review will be guided by the Arksey and O'Malley six-step methodological framework and the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Review checklist.Both peer reviewed manuscript and pre-prints/abstracts will be evaluated, but studies that have not been peer reviewed will be notated in the summary table. Conference abstracts are excluded.Preliminary and final themes and results identified by this scoping review will be communicated to stakeholders, including hospital staff and HCW, to ensure agreement with our interpretation and to convey knowledge gained with our population of interest.This review will advance the field's current understanding of mechanisms connecting the burnout and pathogenic stress to biologic and physiologic outcomes in healthcare workers and provide researchers with gaps in the literature to inform opportunities for future research.
新冠疫情给医护人员的身心健康带来了压力。工作压力增加和资源有限导致这一群体中焦虑、抑郁、失眠和创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)症状增多。与压力相关的疾病与包括心脏代谢紊乱、内分泌紊乱和过早死亡在内的长期后果密切相关。本综述旨在探讨医护人员倦怠、创伤后应激障碍及其他心理健康相关症状的现有文献,以综合与生理和生物标志物的关系,这些标志物可能与疾病风险增加有关,从而有机会总结当前生物标志物知识并识别该文献中的空白。
本综述采用阿克斯和奥马利的六步综述方法框架。研究团队将使用与健康科学图书馆员合作制定的检索策略选择合适的原始资料。三位评审员将首先筛选从文献检索中获得的标题和摘要,两位评审员将对全文研究进行独立评审以确定是否纳入。研究团队将审查聚焦于哪些与倦怠和/或创伤后应激障碍相关的生理和生物标志物已被研究、用于研究它们的方法以及生物标志物与经历倦怠/创伤后应激障碍的医护人员之间的相关性的文献。两位评审员将为纳入研究填写数据提取表,并将指导文献综合与分析以确定共同主题。
本综述无需伦理批准。我们期望本综述的结果能识别文献中的空白,并鼓励未来开展关于改善医护人员生物和生理标志物研究的研究。初步结果和一般主题将反馈给利益相关者。结果将通过同行评审出版物、政策简报和会议进行传播,并向利益相关者展示,以努力投资于医护人员的身心健康。
这将是第一项评估当前对倦怠对医护人员生物和生理影响理解的综述。目标人群仅限于医护人员;然而,所确定研究空白可用于指导未来对其他高倦怠职业和行业的研究。本综述将以阿克斯和奥马利的六步方法框架以及系统评价和元分析扩展的综述清单的首选报告项目为指导。同行评审手稿和预印本/摘要都将被评估,但未经过同行评审的研究将在汇总表中注明。会议摘要被排除。本综述确定的初步和最终主题及结果将传达给利益相关者,包括医院工作人员和医护人员,以确保与我们的解释一致,并传达我们从感兴趣人群中获得的知识。本综述将推动该领域目前对医护人员倦怠和致病压力与生物和生理结果之间联系机制的理解,并为研究人员提供文献中的空白,以为未来研究机会提供信息。