Division of Hospital Medicine, NYU Langone Health, and assistant director of Precision Medical Education, Institute for Innovations in Medical Education, NYU Grossman School of Medicine, New York, USA.
Department of Emergency Medicine, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California, USA.
Perspect Med Educ. 2023 May 17;12(1):149-159. doi: 10.5334/pme.1013. eCollection 2023.
Competency-based medical education (CBME) is an outcomes-based approach to education and assessment that focuses on what competencies trainees need to learn in order to provide effective patient care. Despite this goal of providing quality patient care, trainees rarely receive measures of their clinical performance. This is problematic because defining a trainee's learning progression requires measuring their clinical performance. Traditional clinical performance measures (CPMs) are often met with skepticism from trainees given their poor individual-level attribution. Resident-sensitive quality measures (RSQMs) are attributable to individuals, but lack the expeditiousness needed to deliver timely feedback and can be difficult to automate at scale across programs. In this eye opener, the authors present a conceptual framework for a new type of measure - TRainee Attributable & Automatable Care Evaluations in Real-time (TRACERs) - attuned to both automation and trainee attribution as the next evolutionary step in linking education to patient care. TRACERs have five defining characteristics: (for patient care and trainees), (sufficiently to the trainee of interest), (minimal human input once fully implemented), (across electronic health records [EHRs] and training environments), and (amenable to formative educational feedback loops). Ideally, TRACERs optimize all five characteristics to the greatest degree possible. TRACERs are uniquely focused on measures of clinical performance that are captured in the EHR, whether routinely collected or generated using sophisticated analytics, and are intended to complement (not replace) other sources of assessment data. TRACERs have the potential to contribute to a national system of high-density, trainee-attributable, patient-centered outcome measures.
基于能力的医学教育 (CBME) 是一种以成果为导向的教育和评估方法,侧重于学员为提供有效的患者护理所需学习的能力。尽管这一目标是提供高质量的患者护理,但学员很少收到他们临床表现的衡量标准。这是有问题的,因为定义学员的学习进展需要衡量他们的临床表现。鉴于传统临床绩效衡量标准 (CPMs) 在个体层面上的归因效果不佳,学员通常对其持怀疑态度。以个人为基础的居民敏感质量衡量标准 (RSQMs) 归因于个人,但缺乏及时提供反馈所需的迅速性,并且在整个计划中难以大规模自动化。在这篇发人深省的文章中,作者提出了一种新概念框架,用于一种新型衡量标准 - 实时学员归因和可自动化的护理评估 (TRACERs) - 既适应自动化,又适应学员归因,作为将教育与患者护理联系起来的下一个演进步骤。TRACERs 有五个定义特征:(针对患者护理和学员)、(对感兴趣的学员来说足够详细)、(一旦完全实施,所需的人工输入最少)、(跨越电子健康记录 [EHR] 和培训环境)、和(易于形成性教育反馈循环)。理想情况下,TRACERs 将所有五个特征优化到最大程度。TRACERs 专门关注在 EHR 中捕获的临床绩效衡量标准,无论是常规收集的还是使用复杂分析生成的,旨在补充(而不是替代)其他评估数据源。TRACERs 有可能为国家高密度、学员归因、以患者为中心的结果衡量标准系统做出贡献。