School of Communication Sciences and Disorders, University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida.
AdventHealth, Florida.
Semin Speech Lang. 2023 Jun;44(3):170-188. doi: 10.1055/s-0043-1764201. Epub 2023 May 23.
This pilot study examined the impact of feedback type on learning a novel speech task, as measured by listener ratings, and will inform procedures for future investigations within a larger sample size. Twenty-four native monolingual English-speaking college-aged adults participated in a single training session to learn novel Hindi phrases. Participants were randomly placed into one of three feedback groups: knowledge of performance (KP), knowledge of results (KR), or a combined KP + KR condition. Participant performance was assessed at 1 day and 1 week post-training. Participant responses were audio recorded and judged for intelligibility, precision, and naturalness by native Hindi speakers, blind to the feedback conditions, via rating scales. At 2 days post-training, participants in the KP and KP + KR feedback conditions were rated as performing better than participants in the KR condition on all three perceptual measures. At 1 week post-training, participants in the KP feedback condition were judged to be superior across all three perceptual measures. Preliminary findings suggest that augmented feedback enhances learning, especially when skills are considered novel and learners are unable to rely on their own internal feedback. These results may have implications for the application of motor learning principles into clinical practice for persons with motor speech disorders.
本初步研究通过倾听者评分,考察了不同反馈类型对学习新言语任务的影响,为今后更大样本量的研究提供了依据。24 名以英语为母语的单语成年大学生参与了一次学习新印地语短语的单一培训课程。参与者被随机分配到三种反馈类型之一:绩效知识反馈(KP)、结果知识反馈(KR)或 KP+KR 混合反馈条件。参与者在培训后第 1 天和第 1 周接受评估。参与者的反应被录音,并由不了解反馈条件的母语为印地语的人通过评分量表对可理解度、准确性和自然度进行判断。在培训后第 2 天,KP 和 KP+KR 反馈条件下的参与者在所有三个感知测量中表现优于 KR 反馈条件下的参与者。在培训后第 1 周,KP 反馈条件下的参与者在所有三个感知测量中表现更优。初步结果表明,增强反馈有助于学习,尤其是当技能被认为是新颖的,并且学习者无法依赖自己的内部反馈时。这些结果可能对将运动学习原则应用于运动言语障碍患者的临床实践具有重要意义。