Chen Joyce L, Fujii Shinya, Schlaug Gottfried
Sunnybrook Research Institute, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation Sciences Institute, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Disabil Rehabil. 2016;38(11):1115-1124. doi: 10.3109/09638288.2015.1076530. Epub 2015 Aug 28.
After practice, augmented feedback is the most important factor that facilitates motor learning. We assess the potential effectiveness of two types of augmented auditory feedback on the re-learning of arm reaching in individuals with stroke: (a) real-time knowledge of performance (KP) feedback and (b) rhythmic cueing in the form of knowledge of results (KR) feedback.
Five participants with stroke underwent short-term practice, reaching with their affected arm with KP, KR and no feedback, on separate days. We assessed range of motion of the upper extremity (shoulder, elbow) and trunk, mean error and variability of the performed trajectory, and movement time, before and after training.
All participants benefitted from practice with feedback, though the effects varied across participants and feedback type. In three participants, KP feedback increased elbow extension and reduced compensatory trunk flexion. In four participants, KR feedback reduced movement time taken to perform the reach. Of note, one participant benefitted mostly from KP feedback, which increased shoulder flexion and elbow extension, and decreased compensatory trunk flexion and mean error.
Within day practice with augmented auditory feedback improves reaching in individuals with stroke. This warrants further investigation with longer practice periods in a larger sample size.
After practice, augmented feedback is the second most important factor that facilitates motor learning. Music-based augmented auditory feedback has potential to enhance reaching abilities in individuals with stroke. Future studies are warranted to evaluate the long-term effectiveness of this feedback over a longer training period in a larger sample size.
在练习之后,增强反馈是促进运动学习的最重要因素。我们评估两种类型的增强听觉反馈对中风患者手臂伸展再学习的潜在效果:(a)实时表现知识(KP)反馈和(b)以结果知识(KR)反馈形式的节奏提示。
五名中风患者在不同日期分别进行短期练习,用患侧手臂进行伸展,分别接受KP反馈、KR反馈和无反馈。我们在训练前后评估了上肢(肩部、肘部)和躯干的活动范围、所执行轨迹的平均误差和变异性以及运动时间。
所有参与者都从有反馈的练习中受益,尽管效果因参与者和反馈类型而异。在三名参与者中,KP反馈增加了肘部伸展并减少了代偿性躯干屈曲。在四名参与者中,KR反馈减少了完成伸展动作所需的运动时间。值得注意的是,一名参与者主要从KP反馈中受益,该反馈增加了肩部屈曲和肘部伸展,并减少了代偿性躯干屈曲和平均误差。
在一天内进行增强听觉反馈的练习可改善中风患者的伸展能力。这需要在更大样本量和更长练习期的情况下进行进一步研究。
在练习之后,增强反馈是促进运动学习的第二重要因素。基于音乐的增强听觉反馈有潜力增强中风患者的伸展能力。未来的研究有必要在更大样本量和更长训练期的情况下评估这种反馈的长期效果。