School of Mechanical Engineering, Sungkyunkwan University, Suwon-Si, Gyeonggi-Do, 16419, Republic of Korea.
Department of Robotics and Mechatronics Engineering, Daegu Gyeongbuk Institute of Science and Technology (DGIST), Daegu, 42988, Republic of Korea.
J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2023 May 25;20(1):66. doi: 10.1186/s12984-023-01189-6.
Upper-limb rehabilitation robots provide repetitive reaching movement training to post-stroke patients. Beyond a pre-determined set of movements, a robot-aided training protocol requires optimization to account for the individuals' unique motor characteristics. Therefore, an objective evaluation method should consider the pre-stroke motor performance of the affected arm to compare one's performance relative to normalcy. However, no study has attempted to evaluate performance based on an individual's normal performance. Herein, we present a novel method for evaluating upper limb motor performance after a stroke based on a normal reaching movement model.
To represent the normal reaching performance of individuals, we opted for three candidate models: (1) Fitts' law for the speed-accuracy relationship, (2) the Almanji model for the mouse-pointing task of cerebral palsy, and (3) our proposed model. We first obtained the kinematic data of healthy (n = 12) and post-stroke (n = 7) subjects with a robot to validate the model and evaluation method and conducted a pilot study with a group of post-stroke patients (n = 12) in a clinical setting. Using the models obtained from the reaching performance of the less-affected arm, we predicted the patients' normal reaching performance to set the standard for evaluating the affected arm.
We verified that the proposed normal reaching model identifies the reaching of all healthy (n = 12) and less-affected arm (n = 19; 16 of them showed an R > 0.7) but did not identify erroneous reaching of the affected arm. Furthermore, our evaluation method intuitively and visually demonstrated the unique motor characteristics of the affected arms.
The proposed method can be used to evaluate an individual's reaching characteristics based on an individuals normal reaching model. It has the potential to provide individualized training by prioritizing a set of reaching movements.
上肢康复机器人为脑卒中患者提供重复的上肢运动训练。除了预先设定的运动模式外,机器人辅助训练方案还需要进行优化,以适应个体独特的运动特征。因此,一种客观的评估方法应该考虑到受影响手臂的卒中前运动表现,以将其表现与正常情况进行比较。然而,目前尚无研究尝试基于个体的正常表现来评估其运动表现。在这里,我们提出了一种基于正常上肢运动模型来评估脑卒中后上肢运动表现的新方法。
为了表示个体的正常上肢运动表现,我们选择了三个候选模型:(1)用于速度准确性关系的 Fitts 定律,(2)用于脑瘫患者鼠标点击任务的 Almanji 模型,以及(3)我们提出的模型。我们首先使用机器人获取健康(n=12)和卒中后(n=7)患者的运动学数据,以验证模型和评估方法,并在临床环境中对一组卒中后患者(n=12)进行了初步研究。我们使用来自未受影响手臂的运动表现获得的模型,预测了患者的正常上肢运动表现,以确定评估受影响手臂的标准。
我们验证了提出的正常上肢运动模型可以识别所有健康个体(n=12)和未受影响手臂(n=19;其中 16 个表现出 R>0.7)的上肢运动,但无法识别受影响手臂的错误上肢运动。此外,我们的评估方法直观且可视化地展示了受影响手臂的独特运动特征。
该方法可用于基于个体的正常上肢运动模型评估个体的上肢运动特征。它具有根据个体的运动特征优先选择一组上肢运动进行个性化训练的潜力。