Department of Cardiology, Harvard Medical School, Boston Children's Hospital, 300 Longwood Avenue, Boston, MA, 02115, USA.
Department of Cardiology, University of Tennessee Health Science Center, Le Bonheur Children's Hospital, Memphis, TN, USA.
Sci Rep. 2023 Jun 3;13(1):9022. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-34720-9.
Multicenter studies in pediatric cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) improve statistical power and generalizability. However, a structured process for identifying important research topics has not been developed. We aimed to (1) develop a list of high priority knowledge gaps, and (2) pilot the use of a wiki survey to collect a large group of responses. Knowledge gaps were defined as areas that have been either unexplored or under-explored in the research literature. High priority goals were: (1) feasible and answerable from a multicenter research study, and (2) had potential for high impact on the field of pediatric CMR. Seed ideas were contributed by a working group and imported into a pairwise wiki survey format which allows for new ideas to be uploaded and voted upon ( https://allourideas.org ). Knowledge gaps were classified into 2 categories: 'Clinical CMR Practice' (16 ideas) and 'Disease Specific Research' (22 ideas). Over a 2-month period, 3,658 votes were cast by 96 users, and 2 new ideas were introduced. The 3 highest scoring sub-topics were myocardial disorders (9 ideas), translating new technology & techniques into clinical practice (7 ideas), and normal reference values (5 ideas). The highest priority gaps reflected strengths of CMR (e.g., myocardial tissue characterization; implementation of technologic advances into clinical practice), and deficiencies in pediatrics (e.g., data on normal reference values). The wiki survey format was effective and easy to implement, and could be used for future surveys.
多中心儿科心血管磁共振(CMR)研究可提高统计学效能和通用性。然而,尚未制定用于确定重要研究课题的结构化流程。我们旨在:(1)列出一系列高度优先的知识空白;(2)试行使用维基调查来收集大量回复。知识空白是指在研究文献中尚未涉及或涉及不足的领域。高优先级目标是:(1)可通过多中心研究来实现和解答;(2)对儿科 CMR 领域具有潜在的重大影响。初步想法由工作组提供,并导入到一对多的维基调查格式中,该格式允许上传新想法并对其进行投票(https://allourideas.org)。知识空白分为两类:“临床 CMR 实践”(16 个想法)和“特定疾病研究”(22 个想法)。在两个月的时间内,96 名用户进行了 3658 次投票,并提出了 2 个新想法。得分最高的三个子主题是心肌疾病(9 个想法)、将新技术和技术转化为临床实践(7 个想法)以及正常参考值(5 个想法)。优先级最高的空白反映了 CMR 的优势(例如心肌组织特征化;将技术进步应用于临床实践),以及儿科领域的不足(例如正常参考值数据)。维基调查格式有效且易于实施,可用于未来的调查。