Department of Radiology, Shanghai Ninth People's Hospital, affiliated to Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine, Shanghai, China.
Department of Otolaryngology, Head & Neck Surgery, Shanghai Ninth People's Hospital, affiliated to Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine, Shanghai, China.
Eur Radiol. 2023 Nov;33(11):7934-7941. doi: 10.1007/s00330-023-09806-7. Epub 2023 Jun 7.
To distinguish geniculate ganglion venous malformation (GGVM) from schwannoma (GGS) by using high-resolution CT (HRCT), routine MRI, and dynamic T1-weighted imaging (T1WI) characteristics.
Surgically confirmed GGVMs and GGSs between 2016 and 2021 were retrospectively included. Preoperative HRCT, routine MR, and dynamic T1WI were performed on all patients. Clinical data, imaging characteristics including lesion size, involvement of facial nerve (FN), signal intensity, enhancement pattern on dynamic T1WI, and bone destruction on HRCT were evaluated. Logistic regression model was developed to identify independent factors for GGVMs, and the diagnostic performance was accessed by receiving operative curve (ROC) analysis. Histological characteristics were explored for both GGVMs and GGSs.
Twenty GGVMs and 23 GGSs with mean age of 31 were included. On dynamic T1WI, 18 GGVMs (18/20) showed "pattern A" enhancement (a progressive filling enhancement), while all 23 GGSs showed "pattern B" enhancement (a gradual whole-lesion enhancement) (p < 0.001). Thirteen GGVMs (13/20) showed the "honeycomb" sign whereas all GGS (23/23) showed extensive bone changes on HRCT (p < 0.001). Lesion size, involvement of FN segment, signal intensity on non-contrast T1WI and T2-weighted imaging (T2WI), and homogeneity on enhanced T1WI were obviously differed between two lesions (p < 0.001, p = 0.002, p < 0.001, p = 0.01, p = 0.02, respectively). Regression model showed the "honeycomb" sign and "pattern A" enhancement were independent risk factors. Histologically, GGVM was characterized by interwoven dilated and tortuous veins, while GGS was characterized by abundant spindle cells with dense arterioles or capillaries.
The "honeycomb" sign on HRCT and "pattern A" enhancement on dynamic T1WI are the most promising imaging characteristics for differentiating GGVM from GGS.
The characteristic sign and enhancement pattern on HRCT and dynamic T1-weighted imaging allow preoperative differentiation of geniculate ganglion venous malformation and schwannoma feasible, which will improve clinical management and benefit patient prognosis.
• The "honeycomb" sign on HRCT is a reliable finding to differentiate GGVM from GGS. • GGVM typically shows "pattern A" enhancement (focal enhancement of the tumor on early dynamic T1WI, followed by progressive contrast filling of the tumor in the delayed phase), while "pattern B" enhancement (gradual heterogeneous or homogeneous enhancement of the whole lesion) is observed in GGS on dynamic T1WI.
通过高分辨率 CT(HRCT)、常规 MRI 和动态 T1 加权成像(T1WI)特征来区分膝状神经节静脉畸形(GGVM)和神经鞘瘤(GGS)。
回顾性纳入 2016 年至 2021 年间经手术证实的 GGVM 和 GGS 患者。所有患者均行术前 HRCT、常规 MRI 和动态 T1WI 检查。评估临床资料、病灶大小、面神经(FN)受累、信号强度、动态 T1WI 增强模式、HRCT 骨破坏等影像学特征。建立鉴别 GGVM 的独立因素的 logistic 回归模型,并通过接受工作特征曲线(ROC)分析评估诊断性能。探讨 GGVM 和 GGS 的组织学特征。
共纳入 20 例 GGVM 和 23 例 GGS,平均年龄为 31 岁。在动态 T1WI 上,18 例 GGVM(18/20)呈“模式 A”增强(肿瘤进行性充盈增强),而 23 例 GGS 均呈“模式 B”增强(整个病变逐渐增强)(p<0.001)。13 例 GGVM(13/20)呈“蜂窝状”征,而所有 GGS(23/23)在 HRCT 上均显示广泛的骨改变(p<0.001)。病变大小、FN 节段受累、非增强 T1WI 和 T2WI 信号强度以及增强 T1WI 均匀性在两种病变之间存在明显差异(p<0.001,p=0.002,p<0.001,p=0.01,p=0.02,分别)。回归模型显示“蜂窝状”征和“模式 A”增强是独立的危险因素。组织学上,GGVM 的特征为交织扩张迂曲的静脉,而 GGS 的特征为丰富的梭形细胞伴密集的小动脉或毛细血管。
HRCT 上的“蜂窝状”征和动态 T1WI 上的“模式 A”增强是鉴别 GGVM 和 GGS 的最有前途的影像学特征。
HRCT 和动态 T1 加权成像上的特征性征象和增强模式可在术前区分膝状神经节静脉畸形和神经鞘瘤,从而改善临床管理并有利于患者预后。
• HRCT 上的“蜂窝状”征是区分 GGVM 和 GGS 的可靠征象。• GGVM 通常表现为“模式 A”增强(肿瘤在早期动态 T1WI 上呈局灶性增强,随后在延迟期肿瘤逐渐增强),而 GGS 在动态 T1WI 上表现为“模式 B”增强(整个病变逐渐不均匀或均匀增强)。