Birmingham City University, Faculty of Health, Education and Life Sciences, Westbourne Road, Birmingham, B15 3TN, England.
Midwifery. 2023 Sep;124:103750. doi: 10.1016/j.midw.2023.103750. Epub 2023 Jun 1.
Excessive levels of gestational weight gain (GWG) are linked with poorer health outcomes for mother and baby, including an increased risk of pregnancy-related hypertension, labour induction, caesarean delivery and increased birth weight.
To explore literature relating to midwives' experiences and challenges and identify interventions relating to GWG.
This review was conducted in accordance with the Joanna Briggs Institute methodology for mixed methods systematic reviews. CINAHL complete, APA PsycArticles, APA PsycInfo, the Cochrane Library and MEDLINE were systematically searched in May 2022. Search terms related to midwives, advice, weight management and experiences were used. A PRISMA approach was taken to identify data, and thematic analysis combined with descriptive statistics allowed synthesis and integration.
Fifty-seven papers were included and three overarching themes were generated; i) emotion and weight, ii) ability to influence and iii) practical challenges and strategies for success. Weight was consistently described as a sensitive topic. Challenges included level of expertise and comfort, perceptions of ability to influence and an awareness of incongruence of midwives' own weight and the advice they are delivering. Interventions evaluated well with some self-reports of improved knowledge and confidence. There was no evidence of impact on practice or GWG.
Although addressing maternal weight gain is an international priority due to the significant risks incurred, in this review we have identified multiple challenges for midwives to support women in healthy weight management. Identified interventions targeting midwives do not directly address the challenges identified and are therefore likely to be insufficient to improve existing practice.
Partnership working and co-creation with women and midwives is essential to ensure knowledge about maternal weight gain is effectively shared across communities to catalyse change.
妊娠体重过度增加(GWG)与母婴健康不良结局有关,包括妊娠高血压、引产、剖宫产和出生体重增加的风险增加。
探讨与助产士的经验和挑战相关的文献,并确定与 GWG 相关的干预措施。
本综述按照乔安娜·布里格斯研究所混合方法系统综述方法进行。2022 年 5 月,系统检索了 CINAHL 全文、APA PsycArticles、APA PsycInfo、Cochrane 图书馆和 MEDLINE。使用了与助产士、建议、体重管理和经验相关的搜索词。采用 PRISMA 方法确定数据,主题分析结合描述性统计允许综合和整合。
共纳入 57 篇论文,生成了三个总体主题;i)情感与体重,ii)影响能力,iii)实践挑战和成功策略。体重一直被描述为一个敏感的话题。挑战包括专业知识和舒适度水平、影响能力的看法以及助产士自身体重和提供的建议之间的不一致性的意识。评估的干预措施效果良好,一些自我报告显示知识和信心有所提高。没有证据表明对实践或 GWG 有影响。
尽管由于承担的重大风险,控制产妇体重增加是国际优先事项,但在本综述中,我们发现助产士在支持妇女健康体重管理方面存在多种挑战。针对助产士的确定干预措施并没有直接解决确定的挑战,因此可能不足以改善现有实践。
与妇女和助产士合作开展伙伴关系和共同创造对于确保社区有效共享有关产妇体重增加的知识以促进变革至关重要。