Department of Psychology, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, 12489 Berlin, Germany
Max Planck Institute for Human Cognitive, Research Group Learning in Early Childhood and Brain Sciences, 04103, Leipzig, Germany.
J Neurosci. 2023 Jun 28;43(26):4896-4906. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.2038-22.2023. Epub 2023 Jun 7.
Does our perception of an object change once we discover what function it serves? We showed human participants ( = 48, 31 females and 17 males) pictures of unfamiliar objects either together with keywords matching their function, leading to semantically informed perception, or together with nonmatching keywords, resulting in uninformed perception. We measured event-related potentials to investigate at which stages in the visual processing hierarchy these two types of object perception differed from one another. We found that semantically informed compared with uninformed perception was associated with larger amplitudes in the N170 component (150-200 ms), reduced amplitudes in the N400 component (400-700 ms), and a late decrease in alpha/beta band power. When the same objects were presented once more without any information, the N400 and event-related power effects persisted, and we also observed enlarged amplitudes in the P1 component (100-150 ms) in response to objects for which semantically informed perception had taken place. Consistent with previous work, this suggests that obtaining semantic information about previously unfamiliar objects alters aspects of their lower-level visual perception (P1 component), higher-level visual perception (N170 component), and semantic processing (N400 component, event-related power). Our study is the first to show that such effects occur instantly after semantic information has been provided for the first time, without requiring extensive learning. There has been a long-standing debate about whether or not higher-level cognitive capacities, such as semantic knowledge, can influence lower-level perceptual processing in a top-down fashion. Here we could show, for the first time, that information about the function of previously unfamiliar objects immediately influences cortical processing within less than 200 ms. Of note, this influence does not require training or experience with the objects and related semantic information. Therefore, our study is the first to show effects of cognition on perception while ruling out the possibility that prior knowledge merely acts by preactivating or altering stored visual representations. Instead, this knowledge seems to alter perception online, thus providing a compelling case against the impenetrability of perception by cognition.
当我们发现一个物体的功能后,我们对它的感知会改变吗?我们向 48 名人类参与者(31 名女性,17 名男性)展示了不熟悉的物体的图片,这些图片要么与匹配其功能的关键词一起出现,导致语义信息感知,要么与不匹配的关键词一起出现,导致非信息感知。我们测量了事件相关电位,以研究这两种类型的物体感知在视觉处理层次上的差异。我们发现,与非信息感知相比,语义信息感知与 N170 成分(150-200 毫秒)的振幅更大、N400 成分(400-700 毫秒)的振幅更小以及 alpha/beta 频段功率的后期下降有关。当同样的物体再次出现而没有任何信息时,N400 和事件相关的功率效应仍然存在,我们还观察到对以前进行过语义信息感知的物体的 P1 成分(100-150 毫秒)的振幅增大。与以前的工作一致,这表明获得关于以前不熟悉物体的语义信息会改变它们的低级视觉感知(P1 成分)、高级视觉感知(N170 成分)和语义处理(N400 成分、事件相关的功率)的各个方面。我们的研究首次表明,这种影响在首次提供语义信息后立即发生,而不需要广泛的学习。长期以来,关于高级认知能力(如语义知识)是否可以自上而下地影响低级知觉处理一直存在争议。在这里,我们首次表明,关于以前不熟悉物体的功能的信息立即影响皮质处理,时间不到 200 毫秒。值得注意的是,这种影响不需要对物体及其相关语义信息进行培训或经验。因此,我们的研究首次表明,认知对感知的影响,同时排除了先前的知识仅仅通过预先激活或改变存储的视觉表示来起作用的可能性。相反,这种知识似乎在线改变感知,从而提供了一个有力的案例,反对认知对感知的不可穿透性。