Gopalan Harison, P Krishnakumar, S Arun
Department of Neurosurgery, Government Medical College, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala, India.
Department of Neurosurgery, Government T. D. Medical College, Alappuzha, Vandanam, Kerala, India.
Ann Neurosci. 2023 Jan;30(1):26-32. doi: 10.1177/09727531221120765. Epub 2022 Sep 20.
Post traumatic seizures (PTS) and post traumatic epilepsy (PTE) are potential consequences of traumatic brain injury (TBI). There is no consensus regarding its management among treating doctors.
We have undertaken a global survey to assess the variability of management practices of PTS and PTE and highlight the pressing need to formulate uniform practice guidelines.
A questionnaire consisting of sixteen questions were developed with the help of Google survey and sent through e-mail, or social media platforms like WhatsApp, Facebook messenger or Telegram, to practicing Neurologists and Neurosurgeons round the world.
There were a total of 220 responses. Majority of our responders (n = 202; 91.8%) would start an anti-epileptic (AED) prophylaxis to prevent PTS; 18 people (8.18%) told that they would not start AED prophylaxis for TBI. Phenytoin (n = 98; 48.5%) followed by Levetiracetam (n = 78; 38.6%) was the preferred drug, although the latter was significantly preferred by high and upper middle-income countries (001). Majority (n = 99; 49%) would not use it beyond two weeks. Most clinicians would manage PTE with a single drug (n = 160; 72.7%) either Phenytoin (n = 69; 31.3%) or levetiracetam (n = 67; 30.4%). Most of them (n = 174; 86%) would treat for less than one year.
Practices in the management of PTS and PTE vary widely among clinicians. Our study point towards the need for the development of a more robust and comprehensive practice guidelines for the management of the same.
创伤后癫痫发作(PTS)和创伤后癫痫(PTE)是创伤性脑损伤(TBI)的潜在后果。治疗医生对其管理尚无共识。
我们进行了一项全球调查,以评估PTS和PTE管理实践的变异性,并强调制定统一实践指南的迫切需求。
借助谷歌调查设计了一份包含16个问题的问卷,并通过电子邮件或WhatsApp、Facebook Messenger或Telegram等社交媒体平台发送给世界各地的神经科医生和神经外科医生。
共收到220份回复。大多数回复者(n = 202;91.8%)会开始使用抗癫痫药物(AED)预防PTS;18人(8.18%)表示他们不会对TBI开始使用AED预防。苯妥英钠(n = 98;48.5%)其次是左乙拉西坦(n = 78;38.6%)是首选药物,尽管高收入和中高收入国家显著更倾向于后者(001)。大多数(n = 99;49%)不会使用超过两周。大多数临床医生会用单一药物治疗PTE(n = 160;72.7%),要么是苯妥英钠(n = 69;31.3%)要么是左乙拉西坦(n = 67;30.4%)。他们中的大多数(n = 174;86%)会治疗不到一年。
临床医生在PTS和PTE管理方面的实践差异很大。我们的研究表明需要制定更完善、更全面的管理实践指南。