Presset Bastien, Ohl Fabien
Institute of Sport Sciences, Faculty of Social and Political Science, University of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Department of Technology and Society Studies, Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Digit Health. 2023 Jun 7;9:20552076231180731. doi: 10.1177/20552076231180731. eCollection 2023 Jan-Dec.
Scholars have explored the role of self-tracking in mediating people's values, perceptions, and practices. But little is known about its institutionalised forms, although it is becoming a routine component of health policies and insurance programs. Furthermore, the role of structural elements such as sociodemographic variables, socialisations, and trajectories has been neglected. Using both quantitative ( = 818) and qualitative ( = 44) data gathered from users and non-users of an insurance program's self-tracking intervention, and drawing from Bourdieu's theoretical framework, we highlight the impact of users' social background on the adoption and use of the technology. We show that older, poorer, and less educated individual are less likely to adopt the technology, and describe four prototypical categories of users, , , and the . Each category displays different reasons and ways to use the technology that are grounded in users' socialisations and life trajectories. Results suggest that too much emphasis may have been put on self-tracking's transformative powers and not enough on its reproductive inertia, with important consequences for both scholars, designers, and public health stakeholders.
学者们探讨了自我追踪在调节人们的价值观、认知和行为方面的作用。尽管它正成为健康政策和保险计划的常规组成部分,但对于其制度化形式却知之甚少。此外,社会人口统计学变量、社会化和人生轨迹等结构要素的作用也被忽视了。我们使用从保险计划自我追踪干预的使用者和非使用者那里收集的定量数据(n = 818)和定性数据(n = 44),并借鉴布迪厄的理论框架,强调了使用者社会背景对该技术采用和使用的影响。我们表明,年龄较大、较贫穷和受教育程度较低的个体采用该技术的可能性较小,并描述了四类典型使用者,即……以及……。每类使用者展示出基于其社会化和人生轨迹的不同使用该技术的原因和方式。结果表明,人们可能过于强调自我追踪的变革力量,而对其复制惯性关注不足,这对学者、设计师和公共卫生利益相关者都产生了重要影响。