In this work, we outline a simple method for synthesizing decahedral and triangular silver nanoparticles using light to tune particle shape and spectral characteristics. Notably, we were able to generate triangular silver nanoparticles with exceptional absorbance in the near-infrared (NIR) region, with high spectral overlap with the biological window, making them particularly promising for biological applications. We further demonstrate that under complementary LED illumination, these excitable plasmonic particles display exceptional antibacterial properties, several orders of magnitude more potent than similar particles under dark conditions or under illumination that does not match particle absorbance. This work demonstrates the powerful effects that LED lights can have on the antibacterial activity of AgNPs, providing an inexpensive and easily implemented route to unlocking the full potential of AgNPs in photobiological applications.