Zay Hta May Kyi, Ting Rachel Sing-Kiat, Goh Pei Hwa, Gan Qian Hui, Jones Liz
Department of Psychology, Jeffrey Cheah School of Medicine and Health Sciences, Monash University Malaysia, Jalan Lagoon Selatan, Selangor, Malaysia.
Curr Psychol. 2023 Mar 15:1-32. doi: 10.1007/s12144-023-04509-0.
Both public stigma and perceived self-stigma are prevalent during pandemics threatening a divide among the global community. This systematic review examined the cultural factors associated with viral respiratory-related pandemic stigma. Following PRISMA guidelines, the keywords, "culture, stigma, and pandemic" were searched across relevant databases for empirical papers between January 2000 to March 2022. Quality assessment and coding were adopted in the screening process. Thirty-one articles were included in the final analysis. Themes revealed that collectivistic values, cultural identities, and non-western regions were associated with public (others) stigma; mismatch of cultural values, minority groups, and North America, Asia, Oceania, and African regions were associated with higher perceived and self-stigma. We further mapped the themes into a proposed systemic cultural stigma model to integrate the dynamic intersection of cultural values, identity, and ecology. The cultural factors and their influence on stigma were then explained by drawing on two evolutionary theories: Cultural rationality theory and scapegoating theory. Lastly, we proposed culturally sensitive and responsive practices for stigma management at the community level, especially in non-Western regions during the pandemic recovery phase.
在威胁全球社会分裂的大流行期间,公众污名和感知到的自我污名都很普遍。本系统综述研究了与病毒性呼吸道相关大流行污名相关的文化因素。遵循PRISMA指南,在相关数据库中搜索了2000年1月至2022年3月期间关于“文化、污名和大流行”的关键词,以查找实证论文。筛选过程中采用了质量评估和编码。最终分析纳入了31篇文章。主题显示,集体主义价值观、文化身份和非西方地区与公众(他人)污名有关;文化价值观的不匹配、少数群体以及北美、亚洲、大洋洲和非洲地区与更高的感知污名和自我污名有关。我们进一步将这些主题映射到一个拟议的系统性文化污名模型中,以整合文化价值观、身份和生态的动态交叉点。然后借鉴文化理性理论和替罪羊理论这两种进化理论,解释文化因素及其对污名的影响。最后,我们提出了在社区层面进行污名管理的文化敏感和响应性做法,特别是在大流行恢复阶段的非西方地区。