Department of Health Sciences, University of York, York.
Br J Gen Pract. 2023 Jun 29;73(732):e545-e555. doi: 10.3399/BJGP.2022.0544. Print 2023 Jul.
The unadjusted gender pay gap in general practice is reported to be 33.5%. This reflects partly the differential rate at which women become partners, but evidence exploring gender differences in GPs' career progression is sparse.
To explore factors affecting uptake of partnership roles, focusing particularly on gender differences.
Convergent mixed-methods research design using data from UK GPs.
Secondary analysis of qualitative interviews and social media analysis of UK GPs' Twitter commentaries, which informed the conduct of asynchronous online focus groups. Findings were combined using methodological triangulation.
The sample comprised 40 GP interviews, 232 GPs tweeting about GP partnership roles, and seven focus groups with 50 GPs. Factors at individual, organisational, and national levels influence partnership uptake and career decisions of both men and women GPs. Desire for work-family balance (particularly childcare responsibilities) presented the greatest barrier, for both men and women, as well as workload, responsibility, financial investment, and risk. Greater challenges were, however, reported by women, particularly regarding balancing work-family lives, as well as prohibitive working conditions (including maternity and sickness pay) and discriminatory practices perceived to favour men and full-time GPs.
There are some long-standing gendered barriers that continue to affect the career decisions of women GPs. The relative attractiveness of salaried, locum, or private roles in general practice appears to discourage both men and women from partnerships presently. Promoting positive workplace cultures through strong role models, improved flexibility in roles, and skills training could potentially encourage greater uptake.
一般实践中的未经调整的性别薪酬差距据报道为 33.5%。这部分反映了女性成为合伙人的不同速度,但探索全科医生职业发展中性别差异的证据很少。
探讨影响合伙人角色的因素,特别关注性别差异。
使用英国全科医生的数据,采用收敛混合方法研究设计。
对英国全科医生的定性访谈和社交媒体分析的二级分析,为异步在线焦点小组的进行提供了信息。使用方法三角测量法结合了发现结果。
样本包括 40 名全科医生访谈、232 名在推特上发布有关全科医生合伙人角色的 GP 以及 7 个有 50 名 GP 参加的焦点小组。个人、组织和国家各级的因素都影响男性和女性全科医生的合伙人参与和职业决策。工作与家庭平衡的愿望(特别是儿童保育责任)对男性和女性来说都是最大的障碍,还有工作量、责任、财务投资和风险。然而,女性报告的挑战更大,尤其是在平衡工作与家庭生活方面,以及被认为有利于男性和全职全科医生的不利工作条件(包括产假和病假工资)和歧视性做法。
仍有一些长期存在的性别障碍继续影响女性全科医生的职业决策。目前,全科医生中受薪、临时工或私人角色的相对吸引力似乎阻碍了男性和女性成为合伙人。通过树立积极的榜样、提高角色的灵活性和技能培训,促进积极的工作文化,可能会鼓励更多的人参与。