Moureau Audrey, Cordemans Louise, Gregoire Caroline, Benoît Pirmez, Delvenne Veronique
Faculty of Medicine, Université Libre de Bruxelles, Brussels, Belgium.
Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Department, Queen Fabiola Children's University Hospital, Brussels, Belgium.
Front Psychiatry. 2023 Jun 15;14:1121894. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1121894. eCollection 2023.
Psychiatric Mother-Baby Units are well established in France, United Kingdom, and Australia, mostly in full-time hospitalization. Inpatient units are considered as best practice for improving outcomes for mothers and babies when the mother is experiencing severe mental illness and many studies have showed the effectiveness of care for the mother or the mother-infant relationship. Only a limited number of studies have focused on the day care setting or on the development of the baby. Our parent-baby day unit is the first day care unit in child psychiatry in Belgium. It offers specialized evaluation and therapeutic interventions focused on the baby and involves parents with mild or moderate psychiatric symptoms. The advantages of day care unit is to reduce the rupture with social and family living.
The objective of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of parent-baby day unit in prevention of babies' developmental problems. First, we present the clinical characteristics of the population treated in the day-unit in comparison to the features presented in the literature review about mother-baby units, which usually receive full-time treatment. Then, we will identify the factors that might contribute to a positive evolution of the baby's development.
In this study, we retrospectively analyze data of patients admitted between 2015 and 2020 in the day unit. Upon admission, the 3 pillars of perinatal care - babies, parents, and dyadic relationships - have systematically been investigated. All the families have received a standard perinatal medico-psycho-social anamnesis, including data on the pregnancy period. In this unit, all the babies are assessed at entry and at discharge using the diagnostic 0 to 5 scale, a clinical withdrawal risk, and a developmental assessment (Bayley). Parental psychopathology is assessed with the DSM5 diagnostic scale and the Edinburgh scale for depression. Parent-child interactions are categorized according to Axis II of the 0 to 5 scale. We have evaluated the improvement of children symptomatology, the child development and the mother-child relation between the entrance (T1) and the discharge (T2) and we have compared two groups of clinical situations: a group of patients with a successful evolution (considering baby's development and the alliance with the parents) and a group of unsuccessful evolution during hospitalization.
We use descriptive statistics to characterize our population. To compare the different groups of our cohort, we use the -test and non-parametric tests for continue variables. For discrete variables, we used the Chi test of Pearson.
The clinical population of the day unit is comparable to the mother-baby units in terms of psychosocial fragility but the psychopathological profile of the parents entering the day unit shows more anxiety disorder and less post-partum psychosis. The babies' development quotient is in the average range at T1 and is maintained at T2. In the day unit, the number of symptoms as well as the relational withdrawal of the babies is reduced between T1 and T2. The quality of parent-child relationship is improved between T1 and T2. The children of the group of pejorative evolution had a lower developmental quotient at the T1 and an overrepresentation of traumatic life events.
These results indicate that parent-baby day unit lead to positive outcomes in clinical situations with anxio-depressive parents, relational withdrawal of the babies, functional problems of the babies but not when a significant impact on the development of the baby already exists. The results of this study can guide therapeutic approaches for the benefit of care in parent-baby day units, and improve the development of the child and of the dyadic relationships.
母婴精神病单元在法国、英国和澳大利亚已成熟建立,大多采用全日制住院治疗。当母亲患有严重精神疾病时,住院单元被视为改善母婴结局的最佳实践,许多研究已表明对母亲或母婴关系的护理效果显著。仅有少数研究关注日间护理环境或婴儿的发育情况。我们的母婴日间单元是比利时儿童精神病学领域的首个日间护理单元。它提供专注于婴儿的专业评估和治疗干预,并让有轻度或中度精神症状的父母参与其中。日间护理单元的优势在于减少与社会和家庭生活的脱节。
本研究的目的是评估母婴日间单元在预防婴儿发育问题方面的效果。首先,我们将本日间单元所治疗人群的临床特征与文献综述中关于通常接受全日制治疗的母婴单元的特征进行比较。然后,我们将确定可能有助于婴儿发育积极进展的因素。
在本研究中,我们回顾性分析了2015年至2020年期间入住日间单元的患者数据。入院时,系统调查了围产期护理的三个支柱——婴儿、父母和二元关系。所有家庭都接受了标准的围产期医学 - 心理 - 社会病史采集,包括孕期数据。在本单元,所有婴儿在入院时和出院时都使用0至5诊断量表、临床退缩风险评估和发育评估(贝利量表)进行评估。父母的精神病理学用DSM5诊断量表和爱丁堡抑郁量表进行评估。亲子互动根据0至5量表的第二轴进行分类。我们评估了儿童症状学、儿童发育以及母婴关系在入院时(T1)和出院时(T2)的改善情况,并比较了两组临床情况:一组是病情成功进展的患者(考虑婴儿发育和与父母的关系)和一组住院期间病情未成功进展的患者。
我们使用描述性统计来描述我们的人群特征。为了比较我们队列中的不同组,对于连续变量我们使用t检验和非参数检验。对于离散变量,我们使用皮尔逊卡方检验。
日间单元的临床人群在心理社会脆弱性方面与母婴单元相当,但进入日间单元的父母的精神病理学特征显示焦虑症更多,产后精神病更少。婴儿的发育商在T1时处于平均范围,并在T2时保持。在日间单元,婴儿的症状数量以及关系退缩在T1和T2之间减少。母婴关系质量在T1和T2之间得到改善。病情恶化组的儿童在T1时发育商较低,且创伤性生活事件的发生率过高。
这些结果表明,母婴日间单元在父母有焦虑抑郁、婴儿关系退缩、婴儿功能问题但对婴儿发育尚未产生重大影响的临床情况下能带来积极结果。本研究结果可为母婴日间单元的护理治疗方法提供指导,改善儿童发育和二元关系。