Department of Community Medicine and School of Public Health, Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER), Chandigarh-160012, India.
Faculty of Education & Health Sciences, University of Limerick, Ireland.
Nicotine Tob Res. 2023 Sep 4;25(11):1727-1735. doi: 10.1093/ntr/ntad105.
Integrated care is likely to improve outcomes in strained healthcare systems while limiting costs. NCD clinics were introduced under the "National Programme for Prevention and Control of Cancer, Diabetes, Cardiovascular Disease, and Stroke" (NPCDCS) in India; however, there is limited literature on the costs of delivering tobacco cessation interventions within NPCDCS. One of the study's objectives was to estimate the cost of delivering a culturally specific patient-centric behavioral intervention package in two district-level NCD clinics in Punjab, India.
Costing was undertaken using the health systems perspective. A top-down or financial costing approach and a bottom-up or activity-based approach were employed at each step of development and implementation. The opportunity cost was used to include the cost of human resources, infrastructure, and capital resources used. All infrastructure and capital costs were annualized using a 3% annual discount rate. Four additional scenarios were built up concerning three major components to reduce costs further when rolled out on a large scale.
The cost of intervention package development, human resource training, and unit cost of implementation were estimated to be INR 6,47,827 (USD 8,874); INR 134,002 (USD 1810); and INR 272 (USD 3.67), respectively. Based on our sensitivity analysis results, the service delivery cost varied from INR 184 (USD 2.48) to INR 326 (USD 4.40) per patient.
The development costs of the intervention package accounted for the majority proportion of the total cost. Of the total unit cost of implementation, the telephonic follow-up, human resources, and capital resources were the major contributory components.
The current study aims to fill gaps by estimating the unit-level health systems cost of a culturally sensitive, disease-specific, and patient-centric tobacco cessation intervention package delivered at the outpatient settings of NCD clinics at the secondary level hospital, which represents a major link in the health care system of India. Findings from this study could be used to provide supportive evidence to policymakers and program managers for rolling out such interventions in established NCD clinics through the NPCDCS program of the Indian Government.
综合护理可能会改善紧张的医疗体系的治疗效果,同时控制成本。印度“国家癌症、糖尿病、心血管疾病和中风预防和控制计划”(NPCDCS)下设立了非传染性疾病(NCD)诊所,但关于 NPCDCS 中提供戒烟干预措施的成本,相关文献有限。本研究的目的之一是估算在印度旁遮普邦两家区级 NCD 诊所提供一种具有文化针对性的以患者为中心的行为干预方案的成本。
本研究采用卫生系统视角进行成本核算。在方案开发和实施的每一步骤中,均采用自上而下或财务成本核算方法以及自下而上或基于活动的方法。机会成本用于纳入人力资源、基础设施和资本资源的使用成本。所有基础设施和资本成本均按 3%的年贴现率进行年化。此外,还针对三个主要组成部分构建了四个额外的方案,以在大规模推广时进一步降低成本。
干预方案开发、人力资源培训和实施单位成本的估计费用分别为 647827 印度卢比(8874 美元)、134002 印度卢比(1810 美元)和 272 印度卢比(3.67 美元)。基于敏感性分析结果,服务提供成本为每位患者 184 印度卢比(2.48 美元)至 326 印度卢比(4.40 美元)不等。
干预方案的开发成本占总费用的大部分。在实施单位总成本中,电话随访、人力资源和资本资源是主要构成部分。
本研究旨在通过估算在二级医院 NCD 诊所的门诊环境中提供具有文化敏感性、疾病特异性和以患者为中心的戒烟干预方案的单位级卫生系统成本,填补这方面的空白,这是印度医疗保健系统的主要环节。本研究的结果可用于为决策者和项目管理人员提供支持性证据,以便通过印度政府的 NPCDCS 计划在现有的 NCD 诊所中推广此类干预措施。