Zun L, Gold I
Ann Emerg Med. 1986 Aug;15(8):916-22. doi: 10.1016/s0196-0644(86)80675-8.
The mental status examination (MSE) is an integral and universal tool of medicine. We studied the form and content of the MSE performed by emergency physicians. An 11-item questionnaire was developed to determine the indications, amount of time necessary to evaluate mental status, the content of MSEs utilized, and the ideal characteristics of a short, standardized MSE. A study group of a random sample of 120 of 1,174 American Board of Emergency Medicine-certified emergency physicians and a validation group were surveyed by questionnaire, which was returned by 80% and 62%, respectively. Emergency physicians agreed that there are numerous specific indications to evaluate mental status including head injury (99%), behavioral abnormality (98%), drug ingestion (96%), and psychiatric complaint (95%); however, few would test it in abdominal pain (21%) or extremity injury (17%). Seventy-two percent take less than five minutes to evaluate mental status in the emergency department. Most emergency physicians uniformly test the same set of items selected from the formal MSE, including level of consciousness (95%); orientation to time (87%), place (86%), and person (84%); spontaneous speech (80%); and behavioral observation (72%) to evaluate mental status. Almost all of the physicians (82%) perceived a need for, and would use, a short standardized MSE that would take less than five minutes to perform. Results from the validation group confirmed the accuracy of the survey technique used. Our study demonstrated a perceived need for a short, standardized MSE in emergency medicine.
精神状态检查(MSE)是医学中不可或缺的通用工具。我们研究了急诊医生进行的MSE的形式和内容。设计了一份包含11个条目的问卷,以确定评估精神状态的指征、评估所需时间、所使用的MSE内容以及简短标准化MSE的理想特征。对1174名美国急诊医学委员会认证的急诊医生中的120名进行随机抽样组成研究组,并通过问卷对一个验证组进行调查,研究组和验证组问卷的回复率分别为80%和62%。急诊医生一致认为有许多评估精神状态的具体指征,包括头部损伤(99%)、行为异常(98%)、药物摄入(96%)和精神科主诉(95%);然而,很少有人会在腹痛(21%)或肢体损伤(17%)时进行此项检查。72%的人在急诊科评估精神状态的时间不到五分钟。大多数急诊医生统一测试从正式MSE中选取的同一组项目,包括意识水平(95%);时间定向(87%)、地点定向(86%)和人物定向(84%);自发言语(80%);以及行为观察(72%)以评估精神状态。几乎所有医生(82%)都认为需要并会使用一份执行时间少于五分钟的简短标准化MSE。验证组的结果证实了所采用调查技术的准确性。我们的研究表明急诊医学领域认为需要一份简短的标准化MSE。