Department of Medicine, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland, USA.
Department of Medicine, University of Virginia School of Medicine, Charlottesville, Virginia, USA.
Clin Teach. 2023 Aug;20(4):e13597. doi: 10.1111/tct.13597. Epub 2023 Jul 6.
Although a clinician's ability to employ high-value decision-making is influenced by training, many undergraduate medical education programmes lack a formal curriculum in high-value, cost-conscious care. We present a curriculum developed through a cross-institutional collaboration that was used to teach students at two institutions about this topic and can serve as a framework for other institutions to develop similar curricula.
The faculty from the University of Virginia and the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine created a 2-week-long online course to teach medical students the fundamentals of high-value care. The course consisted of learning modules, clinical cases, textbook studies, journal clubs and a competitive 'Shark Tank' final project where students proposed a realistic intervention to promote high-value clinical care.
Over two-thirds of students rated the course's quality as excellent or very good. Most found the online modules (92%), assigned textbook readings (89%) and 'Shark Tank' competition (83%) useful. To evaluate the student's ability to apply the concepts learned during the course in clinical contexts, we developed a scoring rubric based on the New World Kirkpatrick Model to evaluate students' proposals. Groups chosen as finalists (as determined by faculty judges) were more likely to be fourth-year students (56%), achieved higher overall scores (p = 0.03), better incorporated cost impact at several levels (patient, hospital and national) (p = 0.001) and discussed both positive and negative impacts on patient safety (p = 0.04).
This course provides a framework for medical schools to use in their teaching of high-value care. Cross-institutional collaboration and online content overcame local barriers such as contextual factors and lack of faculty expertise, allowed for greater flexibility, and enabled focused curricular time to be spent on a capstone project competition. Prior clinical experience amongst medical students may be an enabling factor in promoting application of learning related to high-value care.
尽管临床医生运用高价值决策的能力受到培训的影响,但许多本科医学教育课程缺乏关于高价值、成本意识护理的正式课程。我们展示了一个通过机构间合作开发的课程,该课程用于在两个机构教授学生这个主题,并可以作为其他机构开发类似课程的框架。
弗吉尼亚大学和约翰霍普金斯大学医学院的教师创建了一个为期两周的在线课程,教授医学生高价值护理的基础知识。该课程包括学习模块、临床病例、教材研究、期刊俱乐部和一个有竞争力的“鲨鱼坦克”最终项目,学生在该项目中提出一个现实的干预措施来促进高价值的临床护理。
超过三分之二的学生对课程质量的评价为优秀或很好。大多数学生认为在线模块(92%)、指定的教材阅读(89%)和“鲨鱼坦克”竞赛(83%)很有用。为了评估学生在临床环境中应用所学概念的能力,我们根据新世界柯克帕特里克模型制定了一个评分标准来评估学生的提案。被选为决赛选手的小组(由教师评委决定)更有可能是四年级学生(56%),总得分更高(p=0.03),更好地在几个层面上考虑了成本影响(患者、医院和国家)(p=0.001),并讨论了对患者安全的正反两方面影响(p=0.04)。
本课程为医学院提供了一个教授高价值护理的框架。机构间合作和在线内容克服了当地的障碍,如背景因素和缺乏教师专业知识,允许更大的灵活性,并使集中的课程时间能够用于顶点项目竞赛。医学生的先前临床经验可能是促进与高价值护理相关的学习应用的一个有利因素。