Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Siriraj Hospital, Mahidol University, Bangkok, Thailand.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China.
PLoS One. 2023 Jul 10;18(7):e0288289. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0288289. eCollection 2023.
International professional organizations recommend aspirin prophylaxis to women screened high risk for preterm preeclampsia (PE) in the first trimester. The UK Fetal Medicine Foundation (FMF) screening test for preterm PE using mean arterial pressure (MAP), uterine artery pulsatility index (UTPI) and placental growth factor (PlGF) was demonstrated to have lower detection rate (DR) in Asian population studies. Additional biomarkers are therefore needed in Asian women to improve screening DRs as a significant proportion of women with preterm and term PE are currently not identified.
To evaluate maternal serum inhibin-A at 11-13 weeks as an alternative to PlGF or as an additional biomarker within the FMF screening test for preterm PE.
This is a nested case-control study using pregnancies initially screened at 11-13 weeks for preterm PE using the FMF triple test in a non-intervention study conducted between December 2016 and June 2018. Inhibin-A levels were retrospectively measured in 1,792 singleton pregnancies, 112 (1.7%) with PE matched for time of initial screening with 1,680 unaffected pregnancies. Inhibin-A levels were transformed to multiple of the expected median (MoM). The distribution of log10 inhibin-A MoM in PE and unaffected pregnancies and the association between log10 inhibin-A MoM and gestational age (GA) at delivery in PE were assessed. The screening performance determined by area under receiver operating characteristic curves (AUC) and detection rates (DRs) at a 10% fixed false positive rate (FPR), for preterm and term PE was determined. All risks for preterm and term PE were based on the FMF competing risk model and Bayes theorem. Differences in AUC (ΔAUC) between different biomarker combinations were compared using the Delong test. McNemar's test was used to assess the off-diagonal change in screening performance at a fixed 10% FPR after adding inhibin-A or replacing PlGF in the preterm PE adjusted risk estimation model.
Inhibin-A levels in unaffected pregnancies were significantly dependent on GA, maternal age and weight and were lower in parous women with no previous history of PE. Mean log10 inhibin-A MoM in any-onset PE (p<0.001), preterm (p<0.001) and term PE (p = 0.015) pregnancies were all significantly higher than that of unaffected pregnancies. Log10 inhibin-A MoM was inversely but not significantly correlated (p = 0.165) with GA at delivery in PE pregnancies. Replacing PlGF with inhibin-A in the FMF triple test reduced AUC and DR from 0.859 and 64.86% to 0.837 and 54.05%, the ΔAUC was not statistically significant. AUC and DR when adding inhibin-A to the FMF triple test were 0.814, 54.05% and the -0.045 reduction in AUC was statistically significant (p = 0.001). At a fixed 10% FPR, replacing PlGF with inhibin-A identified 1 (2.7%) additional pregnancy but missed 5 (13.5%) pregnancies which subsequently developed preterm PE identified by the FMF triple test. Adding inhibin-A missed 4 (10.8%) pregnancies and did not identify any additional pregnancies with preterm PE.
Replacing PlGF by inhibin-A or adding inhibin-A as an additional biomarker in and to the FMF triple screening test for preterm PE does not improve screening performance and will fail to identify pregnancies that are currently identified by the FMF triple test.
国际专业组织建议对孕早期筛查出有早产先兆子痫(PE)高危的女性使用阿司匹林进行预防。英国胎儿医学基金会(FMF)使用平均动脉压(MAP)、子宫动脉搏动指数(UTPI)和胎盘生长因子(PlGF)进行的早产 PE 筛查试验在亚洲人群研究中显示出较低的检出率(DR)。因此,亚洲女性需要额外的生物标志物来提高筛查 DR,因为目前有相当一部分早产和足月 PE 患者无法被识别。
评估 11-13 周时的母血清抑制素-A 作为 PlGF 的替代物,或作为 FMF 早产 PE 筛查试验中的附加生物标志物。
这是一项嵌套病例对照研究,在 2016 年 12 月至 2018 年 6 月期间进行的一项非干预性研究中,使用 FMF 三联试验对 11-13 周的孕妇进行早产 PE 筛查,对最初接受筛查的 112 例(1.7%)PE 患者和 1680 例未受影响的妊娠进行时间匹配。回顾性测量了 1792 例单胎妊娠的抑制素-A 水平,其中 112 例(1.7%)PE 患者与未受影响的妊娠在最初筛查时时间匹配。抑制素-A 水平转换为多个预期中位数(MoM)。评估了 PE 和未受影响妊娠中 log10 抑制素-A MoM 的分布,以及 PE 中 log10 抑制素-A MoM 与分娩时 GA 的关系。通过接收者操作特征曲线(AUC)下的面积和在固定 10%假阳性率(FPR)下的检出率(DR)确定早产和足月 PE 的筛查性能。所有早产和足月 PE 的风险均基于 FMF 竞争风险模型和贝叶斯定理。使用 Delong 检验比较不同生物标志物组合之间 AUC(ΔAUC)的差异。使用 McNemar 检验评估在固定 10%FPR 后添加抑制素-A 或替换 PlGF 在早产 PE 调整风险估计模型中对筛查性能的对角线变化。
未受影响妊娠的抑制素-A 水平与 GA、母亲年龄和体重显著相关,且在无 PE 既往史的多产妇中较低。任何发作 PE(p<0.001)、早产(p<0.001)和足月 PE(p=0.015)孕妇的平均 log10 抑制素-A MoM 均明显高于未受影响的妊娠。PE 妊娠中 log10 抑制素-A MoM 与 GA 呈负相关,但无统计学意义(p=0.165)。在 FMF 三联试验中用抑制素-A 替换 PlGF 会降低 AUC 和 DR 分别从 0.859 和 64.86%到 0.837 和 54.05%,差异无统计学意义。在 FMF 三联试验中添加抑制素-A 时 AUC 和 DR 分别为 0.814 和 54.05%,AUC 减少 0.045 具有统计学意义(p=0.001)。在固定 10%FPR 下,用抑制素-A 替换 PlGF 可额外识别 1 例(2.7%)妊娠,但漏诊了 5 例(13.5%)随后通过 FMF 三联试验确诊的早产 PE 患者。添加抑制素-A 漏诊了 4 例(10.8%)妊娠,且未能识别任何额外的早产 PE 妊娠。
用抑制素-A 替换 PlGF 或在 FMF 三联筛查试验中添加抑制素-A 作为额外的生物标志物并不能提高筛查性能,并且无法识别目前通过 FMF 三联试验识别的妊娠。