KU Leuven, Department of Neurosciences, ExpORL, Leuven, Belgium.
KU Leuven, Department of Electrical Engineering (ESAT), PSI, Leuven, Belgium.
J Neural Eng. 2023 Aug 3;20(4). doi: 10.1088/1741-2552/ace73f.
When a person listens to continuous speech, a corresponding response is elicited in the brain and can be recorded using electroencephalography (EEG). Linear models are presently used to relate the EEG recording to the corresponding speech signal. The ability of linear models to find a mapping between these two signals is used as a measure of neural tracking of speech. Such models are limited as they assume linearity in the EEG-speech relationship, which omits the nonlinear dynamics of the brain. As an alternative, deep learning models have recently been used to relate EEG to continuous speech.This paper reviews and comments on deep-learning-based studies that relate EEG to continuous speech in single- or multiple-speakers paradigms. We point out recurrent methodological pitfalls and the need for a standard benchmark of model analysis.We gathered 29 studies. The main methodological issues we found are biased cross-validations, data leakage leading to over-fitted models, or disproportionate data size compared to the model's complexity. In addition, we address requirements for a standard benchmark model analysis, such as public datasets, common evaluation metrics, and good practices for the match-mismatch task.We present a review paper summarizing the main deep-learning-based studies that relate EEG to speech while addressing methodological pitfalls and important considerations for this newly expanding field. Our study is particularly relevant given the growing application of deep learning in EEG-speech decoding.
当一个人听连续的语音时,大脑中会产生相应的反应,可以用电极脑电图(EEG)记录下来。目前,线性模型用于将 EEG 记录与相应的语音信号相关联。线性模型在这两个信号之间找到映射的能力被用作语音神经跟踪的度量。这些模型是有限的,因为它们假设 EEG-语音关系的线性,而忽略了大脑的非线性动力学。作为替代方案,深度学习模型最近已被用于将 EEG 与连续语音相关联。本文回顾并评论了基于深度学习的研究,这些研究在单人和多人说话者范式中,将 EEG 与连续语音相关联。我们指出了递归方法上的陷阱,以及对模型分析的标准基准的需求。我们收集了 29 项研究。我们发现的主要方法问题是有偏差的交叉验证、导致过度拟合模型的数据泄露,或者与模型的复杂性相比,数据量不成比例。此外,我们还讨论了标准基准模型分析的要求,例如公共数据集、通用评估指标以及匹配不匹配任务的良好实践。我们提交了一篇综述论文,总结了将 EEG 与语音相关联的主要基于深度学习的研究,同时解决了这个新扩展领域的方法学陷阱和重要考虑因素。鉴于深度学习在 EEG 语音解码中的应用越来越多,我们的研究特别相关。