Bramo Senait Samuel, Desta Amare, Syedda Munavvar
Department of Information science, Institute of Technology Jimma University Jimma Ethiopia.
Department of Business Studies, Faculty of Business University of Wales Trinity Saint David London UK.
Learn Health Syst. 2023 Jan 27;7(3):e10360. doi: 10.1002/lrh2.10360. eCollection 2023 Jul.
The implementation of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in the Primary Level Health Care (PLHC) of low-income countries is at the proof-of-concept level. Despite the wide-ranging efforts over the past 35 years, healthcare facilities are grappling with implementation; the essential health information sources are inaccessible. Consequently, the potential benefits are marred by various challenges. Therefore, the aim of this study is to explore the challenges in the implementation of an ICT-Based Health Information system (ICT-BHIS) in the PLHC facilities of Wolaita Zone, South Ethiopia.
We conducted an 8-month ethnographic study to develop and validate the Chibs ICT4H model. More specifically, a total of 160 h of observational data along with 21 key informant interviews were collected in the form of field notes and audio records. Both data were transcribed and entered into the Qualitative Data Analysis mine software version 1.4. Building on the constant comparative method of data analysis, we identified initial themes inductively, revisited the ICT4H model, and expanded and collapsed the themes prior to interpretation to generate new meaning.
The findings of this study revealed that infrastructures, financial cost, technical constraints, human capital, stakeholders' engagement, and organizational commitment are the pressing challenges PLHC facilities face in the implementation of ICT-based health information services.
This implies the need to shift the paradigm/gaze from piecemeals of multiple solo pilot projects to a unified strategy that touches multiple buttons/challenges for the successful implementation of ICT-BHIS in the context of PLHC facilities.
低收入国家在初级卫生保健(PLHC)中实施信息通信技术(ICT)尚处于概念验证阶段。尽管在过去35年里付出了广泛努力,但医疗机构在实施过程中仍面临困境;基本的健康信息来源无法获取。因此,各种挑战削弱了潜在的益处。所以,本研究的目的是探讨在埃塞俄比亚南部沃莱塔地区的初级卫生保健设施中实施基于ICT的健康信息系统(ICT-BHIS)所面临的挑战。
我们开展了一项为期8个月的人种学研究,以开发和验证Chibs ICT4H模型。更具体地说,共收集了160小时的观察数据以及21次关键 informant访谈,以实地笔记和音频记录的形式呈现。这两种数据都进行了转录,并输入到定性数据分析挖掘软件版本1.4中。基于数据分析的持续比较方法,我们归纳性地确定了初始主题,重新审视了ICT4H模型,并在解释之前对主题进行扩展和整合,以产生新的意义。
本研究结果表明,基础设施、财务成本、技术限制、人力资本、利益相关者参与度和组织承诺是初级卫生保健设施在实施基于ICT的健康信息服务时面临的紧迫挑战。
这意味着需要将范式/关注点从多个单独试点项目的零碎方式转变为一种统一战略,该战略要解决多个问题/挑战,以便在初级卫生保健设施背景下成功实施ICT-BHIS。