Kimpo Rhea R, Puder Barb
Department of Basic Sciences, College of Health Sciences, Samuel Merritt University, Oakland, California, USA.
Department of Foundational Sciences, College of Osteopathic Medicine, Touro University, California, Vallejo, California, USA.
Anat Sci Educ. 2023 Nov-Dec;16(6):1046-1057. doi: 10.1002/ase.2316. Epub 2023 Jul 17.
The traditional format for neuroanatomy lab practical exams involves stations with a time limit for each station and inability to revisit stations. Timed exams have been associated with anxiety, which can lead to poor performance. In alignment with the universal design for learning (UDL), Timed Image Question and Untimed Image Question exam formats were designed to determine which format supports student success, especially for those who performed poorly in the traditional format. Only the Untimed Image Question format allowed students to revisit questions. All three formats were administered in a randomized order within a course for three cohorts of medical students. When all students' scores were analyzed together, the type of format had no effect. However, when analyses were conducted only on students who performed poorly in the traditional format, the type of format had an effect. These students increased their score, on average, by at least one grade level in the Untimed Image Question format compared to the traditional format. Students who performed well in the traditional format maintained their A, on average, in the two new formats. More students indicated Untimed Image Question as their most preferred format after experiencing all three formats. Most students associated the inability to revisit questions with high levels of anxiety. A neuroanatomy lab exam format was therefore identified as consistent with the UDL framework such that all students, regardless of test anxiety levels, can equally demonstrate what they learned. This format allowed for unlimited time per question and ability to revisit questions.
神经解剖学实验室实践考试的传统形式包括设置多个站点,每个站点有时间限制且不能返回重新作答。限时考试与焦虑情绪相关,而焦虑可能导致表现不佳。为了符合通用学习设计(UDL),设计了限时图像问题和不限时图像问题两种考试形式,以确定哪种形式有助于学生取得成功,特别是对于那些在传统形式考试中表现不佳的学生。只有不限时图像问题形式允许学生返回重新作答问题。在一门课程中,这三种形式以随机顺序对三组医学生进行了测试。当对所有学生的成绩进行综合分析时,考试形式类型没有影响。然而,当仅对在传统形式考试中表现不佳的学生进行分析时,考试形式类型产生了影响。与传统形式相比,这些学生在不限时图像问题形式下的成绩平均至少提高了一个等级。在传统形式考试中表现出色的学生在这两种新形式下平均仍保持A的成绩。在体验了所有三种形式后,更多学生表示不限时图像问题是他们最喜欢的形式。大多数学生将不能返回重新作答问题与高度焦虑联系在一起。因此,确定了一种与UDL框架一致的神经解剖学实验室考试形式,这样所有学生,无论考试焦虑水平如何,都能平等地展示他们所学的知识。这种形式允许每个问题有无限时间且可以返回重新作答问题。