VA HSR&D Center to Improve Veteran Involvement in Care, VA Portland Health Care System, Portland, OR, USA.
Department of Psychiatry, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, OR, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 2023 Dec;38(16):3574-3580. doi: 10.1007/s11606-023-08317-x. Epub 2023 Jul 18.
Health coaching has shown promise in helping patients manage their chronic disease and in improving health outcomes, yet the implementation of health coaching in healthcare systems is understudied. Further, evidence suggests that interdisciplinary care teams may be more effective in treating chronic pain than usual care. As such, we sought to examine the benefits and drawbacks to embedding health coaches within interdisciplinary pain care teams ("Whole Health Teams").
As part of a multisite clinical trial (at five Veterans Health Administration sites) investigating the effectiveness of a Whole Health Team (WHT) approach to care for patients with chronic pain, qualitative interviews gathered data on how the experience of treating patients in the WHT differed from the experience treating patients outside the WHT, as well as provider experiences coordinating patient care within the WHT.
Twenty-two WHT members, study investigators, and study coordinators.
Data were analyzed using a rapid analysis approach.
Overall, stakeholders perceived considerable synergy within the interdisciplinary pain care team. Each provider brought a different perspective to the patient's health concerns, which stakeholders felt was valuable and increased patient progress towards goals. The team model was also viewed as efficient because everyone was committed to working together and communicating as a team. Logistically, however, stakeholders noted challenges to working as a team, especially regarding patient goal setting. Furthermore, multiple stakeholders believed the care team model required a high degree of dedication to teamwork and communication among its members to be successful.
Embedding health coaches within interdisciplinary pain care teams may improve care processes and accelerate patient progress. Successful implementation would require adequate training, role clarification, and expectation setting to facilitate good communication across all care team members. Additional research is needed to evaluate the clinical outcomes of integrating health coaches on WHTs versus other implementation approaches.
健康教练在帮助患者管理慢性病和改善健康结果方面显示出了一定的前景,但健康教练在医疗保健系统中的实施情况研究不足。此外,有证据表明,跨学科护理团队在治疗慢性疼痛方面可能比常规护理更有效。因此,我们试图研究在跨学科疼痛护理团队(“整体健康团队”)中嵌入健康教练的利弊。
作为一项多站点临床试验(在五个退伍军人事务部站点进行)的一部分,该试验调查了整体健康团队(WHT)方法对慢性疼痛患者护理的有效性,定性访谈收集了关于在 WHT 中治疗患者的经验与在 WHT 之外治疗患者的经验有何不同的数据,以及提供者在 WHT 内协调患者护理的经验。
22 名 WHT 成员、研究调查人员和研究协调员。
使用快速分析方法对数据进行分析。
总体而言,利益相关者认为跨学科疼痛护理团队内部存在相当大的协同作用。每个提供者都从不同的角度看待患者的健康问题,利益相关者认为这是有价值的,并增加了患者朝着目标前进的进度。团队模式也被认为是高效的,因为每个人都致力于共同努力并作为一个团队进行沟通。然而,利益相关者指出,在团队中工作存在后勤方面的挑战,特别是在制定患者目标方面。此外,多位利益相关者认为,成功实施护理团队模式需要其成员高度致力于团队合作和沟通。
在跨学科疼痛护理团队中嵌入健康教练可能会改善护理流程并加速患者的康复进程。成功实施需要进行足够的培训、角色澄清和期望设定,以促进所有护理团队成员之间的良好沟通。需要进一步研究评估将健康教练整合到 WHT 与其他实施方法相比的临床效果。