Dental Hygiene Program, School of Dentistry, Faculty of Medicine & Dentistry, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada.
Can J Dent Hyg. 2023 Jun 1;57(2):117-122. eCollection 2023 Jun.
The Student Health Initiative for the Needs of Edmonton (SHINE) dental clinic is a student-volunteer-operated clinic offering free oral care to low-income individuals. However, little is known about how SHINE impacts access to care. Drawing on Penchansky and Thomas' theory of access, this study assessed patient satisfaction to measure access. For further context, patient-reported oral health concerns and alternative oral care options if SHINE were not available were recorded.
The University of Alberta's Research Ethics Board (Pro 00101981) approved the study. Surveys adapted from Penchansky and Thomas were distributed over 12 weeks to all presenting patients. Survey data were triangulated with observations. Data were represented using descriptive statistics, and variables were compared using Chi-squared tests of independence.
A response rate of 77% (140/170) was achieved. The survey revealed that patients were generally satisfied with access to SHINE. However, observations revealed physical accessibility barriers. Dissatisfaction was correlated with attending SHINE without receiving treatment. Patients primarily presented to SHINE for pain (55%, 76/139). If SHINE were not available, 38% (46/121) of patients reported they would seek care from an alternative oral health professional, 32% (39/121) through an emergency department or physician, and 27% (33/121) would not attain oral health care at all.
SHINE could be seen as addressing the need for access to oral health care services. The remaining barriers to care include long waiting times and clinic capacity to deliver care. A faster triage process may reduce waiting times. However, SHINE cannot provide more oral health care due to clinic capacity. Lastly, access to clinics such as SHINE may reduce visits to emergency departments for oral health care.
埃德蒙顿学生健康倡议牙科诊所(SHINE)是一家由学生志愿者运营的诊所,为低收入人群提供免费的口腔护理。然而,人们对 SHINE 如何影响获得护理的机会知之甚少。本研究借鉴 Penchansky 和 Thomas 的获取理论,通过评估患者满意度来衡量获取机会。此外,还记录了患者报告的口腔健康问题以及如果没有 SHINE 可提供的替代口腔护理选择。
阿尔伯塔大学研究伦理委员会(Pro 00101981)批准了该研究。在 12 周的时间内,向所有就诊患者发放了改编自 Penchansky 和 Thomas 的调查问卷。将问卷调查数据与观察结果进行三角剖分。使用描述性统计数据表示数据,并使用独立性卡方检验比较变量。
实现了 77%(140/170)的应答率。调查显示,患者对 SHINE 的获取途径普遍感到满意。然而,观察结果显示存在物理可达性障碍。未接受治疗而就诊 SHINE 与不满相关。患者主要因疼痛就诊 SHINE(55%,76/139)。如果 SHINE 不可用,38%(46/121)的患者表示他们将寻求替代口腔卫生专业人员的护理,32%(39/121)将通过急诊部门或医生寻求护理,27%(33/121)根本无法获得口腔保健。
可以认为 SHINE 满足了对口腔保健服务获取的需求。护理的其他障碍包括较长的等待时间和诊所提供护理的能力。更快的分诊流程可能会减少等待时间。然而,由于诊所容量,SHINE 无法提供更多的口腔保健。最后,由于 SHINE 等诊所的存在,可能会减少因口腔保健而前往急诊部门就诊的次数。