Thompson John, Horowitz Zane, Blumenberg Adam
Oregon Health and Science University, Department of Emergency Medicine, Portland, OR.
Columbia University Medical Center, Department of Emergency Medicine, New York City, NY.
J Educ Teach Emerg Med. 2020 Jan 15;6(1):S1-S23. doi: 10.21980/J8FD0R. eCollection 2021 Jan.
This simulation is targeted to emergency medicine residents and medical students. This case focuses on the diagnosis and management of botulism toxicity, while highlighting the logistical complications of botulism toxicity.
Botulism is a potentially life-threatening emergency that often presents with subtle symptoms, which can progress to paralysis and respiratory failure. A descending flaccid paralysis is typical, initially affecting smaller muscles such as oculomotor, then larger facial muscles. 1,2 Early indications of respiratory compromise are important to recognize. It is important for emergency medicine physicians to be familiar with botulism and recognize the presentation quickly to safely treat the patient. Clinical findings may include: dilated pupils, diplopia, xerostomia, dysphagia, and nausea and vomiting. 3 Treatment priorities include assessment and management of the airway, close monitoring, and coordinating with local agencies to obtain botulinum antitoxin.1.
By the end of this simulation learners will be able to: 1) develop a differential for descending paralysis and recognize the signs and symptoms of botulism; 2) understand the importance of consulting public health authorities to obtain botulinum antitoxin in a timely fashion; 3) recognize that botulism will progress during the time period antitoxin is obtained. Early indications of respiratory compromise are expected to worsen during this time window.Secondary learning objectives include: 4) employ advanced evaluation for neurogenic respiratory failure such as physical examination, negative inspiratory force (NIF), forced vital capacity (FVC), and partial pressure of carbon dioxide (pCO2), 5) discuss and review the pathophysiology of botulism, 6) discuss the epidemiology of botulism.
This simulation was conducted using a high-fidelity mannequin with intubating capabilities and real-time vital sign monitoring. Following the simulation, the participants underwent a debriefing session and discussion on botulism. This case was designed as a high-fidelity simulation, but it can be adapted to a low-fidelity simulation or case discussion.
Following the simulation and debriefing session, participants were provided with a survey to rate the simulation and provide feedback to instructors. Participants were asked open-ended questions about the strengths and areas of improvement of the case, and were asked to rate how they valued the learning content of the case on a 5-point scale.
Emergency medicine residents expressed positive feedback on the scenario. The residents appreciated the change in clinical course of the patient over time as well as the presentation of botulism. This simulation is an effective way of teaching about botulism to emergency medicine residents. We used a primary nurse asking questions to progress the case and stimulate the learners to think about certain specific aspects of the case, such as the patient's weakness or disposition. Toxicology, botulism, emergency medicine, medical simulation.
本次模拟针对急诊医学住院医师和医学生。该病例聚焦肉毒中毒毒性的诊断和管理,同时突出肉毒中毒毒性的后勤并发症。
肉毒中毒是一种潜在的危及生命的急症,通常表现为细微症状,可进展为瘫痪和呼吸衰竭。典型的是下行性弛缓性麻痹,最初影响较小的肌肉,如动眼肌,然后是较大的面部肌肉。1,2认识到呼吸功能受损的早期迹象很重要。急诊医学医生熟悉肉毒中毒并迅速识别其表现以安全治疗患者很重要。临床发现可能包括:瞳孔散大、复视、口干、吞咽困难、恶心和呕吐。3治疗重点包括气道评估和管理、密切监测以及与当地机构协调以获取肉毒抗毒素。1.
在本次模拟结束时,学习者将能够:1)对下行性麻痹进行鉴别诊断并识别肉毒中毒的体征和症状;2)理解及时咨询公共卫生当局以获取肉毒抗毒素的重要性;3)认识到在获取抗毒素期间肉毒中毒会进展。预计在此时间窗口内呼吸功能受损的早期迹象会恶化。次要学习目标包括:4)对神经源性呼吸衰竭进行高级评估,如体格检查、吸气负压(NIF)、用力肺活量(FVC)和二氧化碳分压(pCO2),5)讨论并复习肉毒中毒的病理生理学,6)讨论肉毒中毒的流行病学。
本次模拟使用具有插管能力和实时生命体征监测功能的高保真人体模型进行。模拟结束后,参与者进行了关于肉毒中毒的汇报和讨论。该病例设计为高保真模拟,但也可改编为低保真模拟或病例讨论。
在模拟和汇报环节结束后,为参与者提供了一份调查问卷,以对模拟进行评分并向教员提供反馈。向参与者询问了关于该病例优点和改进方面的开放式问题,并要求他们以5分制对他们对该病例学习内容的重视程度进行评分。
急诊医学住院医师对该病例情景给予了积极反馈。住院医师赞赏患者临床病程随时间的变化以及肉毒中毒的表现。本次模拟是向急诊医学住院医师教授肉毒中毒的有效方式。我们让一名主管护士提问以推进病例并促使学习者思考病例的某些特定方面,如患者的虚弱或处置情况。毒理学、肉毒中毒、急诊医学、医学模拟。