Moreo Kathleen, Sullivan Shelby, Carter Jeffrey, Heggen Cherilyn
Kathleen Moreo, BSN, BHSA, RN, CCM, CMGT-BC, CDMS, is the founder of Prime Education, LLC (PRIME), an accredited medical education company advancing the science of learning and behavior change for the interprofessional health care team. She is a past president of the Case Management Society of America, past commissioner of the Commission for Case Manager Certification, and a recipient of the CMSA Case Manager of the Year Award. She has published extensively in peer-reviewed medical journals and has authored two books on nursing case management for the American Nurses Association.
Shelby Sullivan, PharmD, is Director, Scientific Affairs, PRIME Education, LLC, Ft. Lauderdale, FL.
Prof Case Manag. 2023;28(5):215-223. doi: 10.1097/NCM.0000000000000657.
PURPOSE/OBJECTIVES: Despite increased emphases on reducing racial disparities in the U.S. health care system, interprofessional care teams may inadvertently perpetuate health disparities through lack of awareness or experience in supporting individualized, patient-centered goals of care. Racial disparities can lead to health inequity. Persistent health disparity gaps exist among Black patients with multiple myeloma (MM) when compared with non-Black patients. Black patients experience a two-fold increase in MM risk and earlier age of onset compared with non-Black patients. Black patients are also less likely to receive timely access to some therapies, undergo autologous stem cell transplant, or enroll in clinical trials. This article describes a large-scale, equity-focused implementation science initiative aimed at identifying and overcoming racial disparities and health inequity among patients with MM through quality improvement goals identified by each of the interprofessional cancer care teams.
Interprofessional cancer care teams in two large oncology systems as well as four community clinics were engaged in this study along with their patients with MM. Geographic areas included the following: Chicago, IL; Washington, DC; Charlotte, NC; Columbus, OH; Denver, CO; and Indianapolis, IN. Interprofessional teams included hematologists/oncologists, primary care physicians, nurse practitioners/physician assistants, and case managers/nurse navigators. Teams collectively examined and compared their own beliefs and attitudes about their patients' goals for MM treatment and management versus those of their patients to uncover and address discordances. Medical records from the clinics were audited to evaluate disparities in treatment and practice at the point of care. Live, team-based audit-feedback sessions were implemented among teams to examine data sets, as well as utilize the data to address interprofessional factors that could enhance more equitable care.
FINDINGS/CONCLUSIONS: Data from comparative surveys between patients and interprofessional team members revealed significant discordances that enabled health care teams to recognize gaps and identify ways to improve patient-centered care, such as shared decision-making. Through audit-feedback sessions, interprofessional teams were able to collaboratively meet and discuss methods to improve access to care coordination services and other strategies aimed at alleviating disparities. Baseline chart audits revealed and confirmed disparities of care including patient/disease characteristics, treatment history, clinical practice metrics, and patient-centered measures. Follow-up chart audits conducted 6 months later measured changes in documented practice behavior. Action plans developed by the interprofessional teams as a result of this study intend to address sustainable reductions in health disparities among patients with MM to improve health equity and overall care.
This implementation science initiative and data results have several implications for case managers caring for diverse patients with MM in both large health systems and smaller community practices. Results punctuate the importance of identifying and supporting diverse patients' individualized goals and preferences in their care journey to mitigate health inequity and maximize health outcomes. The value of working collaboratively as an interprofessional team is evident in the study results, as is the role of the case manager in appropriate resource allocation to mitigate health disparities. Lessons learned from this initiative may also be applied to other case management settings where complex care delivery and interprofessional teams are at work.
目的/目标:尽管美国医疗保健系统越来越重视减少种族差异,但跨专业护理团队可能会因缺乏支持个性化、以患者为中心的护理目标的意识或经验,而无意中使健康差异长期存在。种族差异可能导致健康不平等。与非黑人患者相比,患有多发性骨髓瘤(MM)的黑人患者中持续存在健康差异差距。与非黑人患者相比,黑人患者患MM的风险增加两倍,发病年龄更早。黑人患者也不太可能及时获得某些治疗、接受自体干细胞移植或参加临床试验。本文描述了一项大规模、以公平为重点的实施科学倡议,旨在通过每个跨专业癌症护理团队确定的质量改进目标,识别并克服MM患者中的种族差异和健康不平等。
两个大型肿瘤系统以及四个社区诊所的跨专业癌症护理团队及其MM患者参与了本研究。地理区域包括:伊利诺伊州芝加哥;华盛顿特区;北卡罗来纳州夏洛特;俄亥俄州哥伦布;科罗拉多州丹佛;印第安纳州印第安纳波利斯。跨专业团队包括血液科医生/肿瘤内科医生、初级保健医生、执业护士/医师助理以及病例管理员/护士导航员。团队共同检查并比较他们自己对患者MM治疗和管理目标的信念和态度与患者的信念和态度,以发现并解决不一致之处。对诊所的病历进行审核,以评估护理点的治疗和实践差异。在团队之间开展基于团队的实时审核反馈会议,以检查数据集,并利用这些数据解决可能增强更公平护理的跨专业因素。
研究结果/结论:患者与跨专业团队成员之间的比较调查数据显示出显著的不一致,这使医疗保健团队能够认识到差距,并确定改善以患者为中心的护理的方法,例如共同决策。通过审核反馈会议,跨专业团队能够共同开会并讨论改善护理协调服务获取途径的方法以及其他旨在减轻差异的策略。基线图表审核揭示并确认了护理差异,包括患者/疾病特征、治疗史、临床实践指标以及以患者为中心的措施。6个月后进行的后续图表审核测量了记录的实践行为的变化。跨专业团队因本研究制定的行动计划旨在实现MM患者健康差异的可持续减少,以改善健康公平性和整体护理。
这项实施科学倡议和数据结果对在大型医疗系统和较小社区实践中照顾不同MM患者的病例管理员有若干启示。结果强调了在患者的护理过程中识别并支持不同患者的个性化目标和偏好以减轻健康不平等并最大化健康结果的重要性。研究结果中跨专业团队协作工作的价值显而易见,病例管理员在适当资源分配以减轻健康差异方面的作用也是如此。从这项倡议中学到的经验教训也可能适用于其他复杂护理提供和跨专业团队工作的病例管理环境。