School of Public and Community Health Sciences and Center for Population Health Research, University of Montana, Missoula, MT, USA.
Department of Mathematical Sciences and Center for Population Health Research, University of Montana, Missoula, MT, USA.
Public Health Rep. 2024 May-Jun;139(3):360-368. doi: 10.1177/00333549231186603. Epub 2023 Jul 28.
Spatial clustering of undervaccination leads to increased risk of vaccine-preventable diseases. We identified spatial clustering of undervaccination patterns among children aged <24 months in Montana.
We used Montana's immunization information system data to analyze deidentified vaccination records of children aged <24 months born from January 2015 through November 2017. We measured 3 outcomes that were not mutually exclusive: not completing the combined 7-vaccine series by age 24 months, having an undervaccination pattern indicative of parental hesitancy, and having an undervaccination pattern indicative of structural barriers to timely vaccination. Using geomasked residential addresses, we conducted separate Bernoulli spatial scans with a randomization < .01 to identify spatial clusters consisting of ≥100 children for each outcome and calculated the relative risk of having the undervaccination pattern inside versus outside the cluster.
Of 31 201 children aged <24 months included in our study, 11 712 (37.5%) had not completed the combined 7-vaccine series by age 24 months, and we identified 5 spatial clusters of this outcome across Montana. We identified 4 clusters of undervaccination patterns indicative of parental vaccine hesitancy, all in western Montana. The cluster with the largest relative risk (2.3) had a radius of 23.7 kilometers (n = 762 children, < .001). We also identified 4 clusters of undervaccination patterns indicative of structural barriers, with 3 of the largest clusters in eastern Montana.
In Montana, different strategies to increase routine and timely childhood vaccination are needed in distinct areas of this large and predominantly rural state. Immunization information system data can pinpoint areas where interventions to increase vaccination uptake are needed.
疫苗接种不足的空间聚集导致疫苗可预防疾病的风险增加。我们确定了蒙大拿州<24 个月儿童疫苗接种不足模式的空间聚集情况。
我们使用蒙大拿州的免疫信息系统数据,分析了 2015 年 1 月至 2017 年 11 月期间出生的<24 个月大的儿童的匿名疫苗接种记录。我们测量了 3 个互不排斥的结果:在 24 个月大时未完成联合 7 疫苗系列接种、存在父母犹豫不决的疫苗接种不足模式和存在及时接种疫苗的结构障碍的疫苗接种不足模式。使用地理掩蔽的居住地址,我们为每个结果进行了单独的伯努利空间扫描,随机化<.01,以确定包含≥100 名儿童的空间集群,并计算了集群内与集群外存在疫苗接种不足模式的相对风险。
在我们的研究中,纳入了 31201 名<24 个月大的儿童,其中 11712 名(37.5%)在 24 个月大时未完成联合 7 疫苗系列接种,我们在蒙大拿州发现了 5 个该结果的空间集群。我们发现了 4 个父母疫苗犹豫的疫苗接种不足模式集群,都在蒙大拿州西部。具有最大相对风险(2.3)的集群半径为 23.7 公里(n=762 名儿童,<.001)。我们还发现了 4 个结构障碍疫苗接种不足模式集群,其中 3 个最大的集群位于蒙大拿州东部。
在蒙大拿州,在这个大型且以农村为主的州的不同地区,需要采取不同的策略来增加常规和及时的儿童疫苗接种。免疫信息系统数据可以确定需要增加疫苗接种率的干预措施的区域。