Nordland Hospital Trust, Regional Competence Centre for Work and Mental Health, PO Box 1480, 8092, Bodø, Norway.
Department of Community Medicine, UiT, The Arctic University of Norway, PO Box 6050 Langnes, N-9037, Tromsø, Norway.
BMC Public Health. 2023 Jul 28;23(1):1444. doi: 10.1186/s12889-023-16272-9.
In this study we investigated the health-related rehabilitation trajectories of young Norwegian adults between 2004-2019. The study period is interesting because it overlaps with an extensive welfare system reform that occurred in Norway between 2006-2011. In parallel with the reform there was a substantial increase in health-related welfare dependency among young people due to mental health conditions. To better understand this group, we addressed three questions: 1) what were the most typical health-related rehabilitation trajectories for young Norwegians aged 23-27 between 2004-2019, 2) did the trajectories and composition of health-related benefit recipients change overtime and 3) in parallel with the welfare reform, do we see improved labour market outcomes in our study population?
Using high-quality Norwegian registry data, we established four cohorts of Norwegian health-related rehabilitation benefit recipients aged 23-27 in either 2004 (cohort 1), 2008 (cohort 2), 2011 (cohort 3) or 2014 (cohort 4). The follow-up period for each cohort was six years. We used sequence and cluster analyses to identify typical health-related rehabilitation trajectories. In addition, descriptive statistics and multinomial logistic regression were used to scrutinise the relationship between trajectory types, sociodemographic characteristics and cohort membership.
The majority follow trajectories consisting of welfare dependency, unemployment and unstable, low-income work. Both the trajectories and composition of the study population changed across cohorts. Over the observation period there was a 1) three-fold increase in the proportion following a trajectory ending in permanent disability benefits, 2) nine-fold increase in the proportion following trajectories characterised by long periods of health-related rehabilitation, 3) five-fold decrease in the share following unemployment occupational handicap trajectories 4) 6.9% increase in the proportion of early school leavers and 5) 8.9% decrease in the share with disabled parents.
Our study population is a vulnerable group with suboptimal mental health, functioning and employment outcomes. In conjunction with the welfare reform, we witnessed a significant drop in use of work-related benefits, accompanied by a substantial increase in uptake of health-related rehabilitation- and disability benefits. Thus, it appears that rather than improving employment outcomes, welfare policy changes have created a new problem by steering a greater proportion into disability benefits.
本研究调查了 2004-2019 年间挪威年轻成年人的与健康相关的康复轨迹。研究期间很有趣,因为它与 2006-2011 年期间在挪威发生的广泛的福利制度改革相重叠。随着改革的进行,由于心理健康状况,年轻人对与健康相关的福利的依赖程度大幅增加。为了更好地了解这一群体,我们提出了三个问题:1)2004-2019 年间,23-27 岁的挪威年轻人最典型的与健康相关的康复轨迹是什么,2)与健康相关的受益人的轨迹和构成是否随时间变化,3)随着福利改革,我们在研究人群中是否看到了劳动力市场结果的改善?
使用高质量的挪威登记数据,我们建立了四个年龄在 23-27 岁之间的挪威与健康相关的康复福利受助人队列,分别为 2004 年(队列 1)、2008 年(队列 2)、2011 年(队列 3)或 2014 年(队列 4)。每个队列的随访期为六年。我们使用序列和聚类分析来确定典型的与健康相关的康复轨迹。此外,我们还使用描述性统计和多项逻辑回归来研究轨迹类型、社会人口特征和队列成员之间的关系。
大多数人遵循的轨迹包括福利依赖、失业和不稳定、低收入工作。研究人群的轨迹和构成在各队列中都发生了变化。在观察期间,1)接受永久性残疾福利的比例增加了三倍,2)接受长期健康相关康复的比例增加了九倍,3)接受与失业相关的职业障碍轨迹的比例下降了五倍,4)中途退学的比例增加了 6.9%,5)有残疾父母的比例下降了 8.9%。
我们的研究人群是一个弱势群体,他们的心理健康、功能和就业结果都不理想。随着福利制度改革,我们目睹了与工作相关的福利使用显著减少,同时健康相关的康复和残疾福利的使用率大幅增加。因此,福利政策的变化似乎并没有改善就业结果,反而通过将更多的人引导到残疾福利中,创造了一个新的问题。