Accelerate CIC, Centenary Wing, St Joseph's Hospice, London, United Kingdom.
CRN Eastern, Norfolk Community Health and Care Trust, Norwich, United Kingdom.
Adv Wound Care (New Rochelle). 2023 Dec;12(12):671-679. doi: 10.1089/wound.2023.0058. Epub 2023 Sep 5.
Randomized controlled trials using complete healing as an endpoint suffer from poor statistical power, owing to the heterogeneity of wounds and their healing trajectories. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has recently consulted with expert groups to consider percentage area reduction (PAR) of the wound over a 4-week period as a valid intermediate endpoint, creating the opportunity for more powerful study designs. A within-subject controlled study design comparing the PAR of venous leg ulcers (VLU) in patients over 4 weeks receiving different interventions. Twenty-nine patients received multilayer compression over 4 weeks, followed by neuromuscular electrostimulation (NMES) of the leg muscle pump in addition to compression for a further 4 weeks. Paired comparison was then made of PAR between the two phases. A second cohort of 22 patients received only multilayer compression throughout both 4-week phases. Patients randomized to NMES saw a significant increase in healing rate compared with compression alone, whereas patients receiving compression only saw no significant change in healing rate throughout the course of the study. Intermittent NMES of the common peroneal nerve significantly accelerates the healing of VLU. It is well tolerated by patients and deserves serious consideration as an adjuvant to compression therapy. PAR is a useful metric for comparing the performance of wound healing interventions, and the self-controlled trial design allows sensitive discrimination with a relatively small number of subjects over a reasonably short trial period. The study is reported according to the CONSORT reporting guidelines. NCT03396731 (ClinicalTrials.gov).
随机对照试验以完全愈合作为终点,由于伤口及其愈合轨迹的异质性,其统计效力较差。美国食品和药物管理局(FDA)最近咨询了专家组,考虑将 4 周内伤口面积减少(PAR)作为有效的中间终点,从而为更有力的研究设计创造了机会。
一项在 4 周内接受不同干预措施的患者中比较静脉溃疡(VLU)PAR 的个体内对照研究设计。29 例患者接受多层压缩治疗 4 周,随后在压缩治疗的基础上对腿部肌肉泵进行神经肌肉电刺激(NMES)治疗 4 周。然后对两个阶段的 PAR 进行配对比较。第二组 22 例患者在两个 4 周阶段均仅接受多层压缩治疗。
与单纯压缩治疗相比,接受 NMES 治疗的患者的愈合速度明显加快,而仅接受压缩治疗的患者在整个研究过程中愈合速度无明显变化。腓总神经间歇性 NMES 可显著加速 VLU 的愈合。它被患者很好地耐受,作为加压治疗的辅助手段值得认真考虑。PAR 是比较伤口愈合干预措施性能的有用指标,并且自我对照试验设计允许在相对较短的试验期内使用相对较少的受试者进行敏感区分。该研究按照 CONSORT 报告指南进行报告。NCT03396731(ClinicalTrials.gov)。