School of Dentistry, Faculty of Medical Sciences, International University of Ecuador, Quito, Ecuador.
PLoS One. 2023 Aug 3;18(8):e0278791. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0278791. eCollection 2023.
The use of an external dome aerosol containment device (Prime Protector) is proposed to reduce the spread of particles within the dental office. Hence, the aim of our study was to compare the spread of bioaerosols generated by a High-speed Handpiece (HH) and an Ultrasonic Prophylaxis Device (UPD), with and without the Prime Protector dome (PP) by counting Colony Forming Units (CFU) of Lactobacillus casei Shirota, at different distances on the x and y axis. The PP was located considering the parallelism between the base of the dome and the frontal plane of the simulator, aligning the center of the mouth with the center of the dome. The PP dome measurements are 560.0mm x 255.0mm x 5mm. Petri dishes were placed at 0.5 m, 1 m and 1.5 m respectively. Aerosol generation in the laboratory environment was done three times with the following experimental groups 1) HH, 2) HH-PP, 3) UPD, 4) UPD-PP. Each dental device activation (HH and UPD) had a time frame of 2 minutes on the upper anterior teeth of the dental phantom with a liquid suspension containing Lactobacillus casei Shirota (YAKULT 0836A 0123; 1027F 0407). Air pressure and ventilation were parameterized. No separate high-volume evacuation used, nor was there any air removal attached to the dome. Results showed no significant difference between distance and axis in the CFU count. When means for devices and distances were compared between each of them all showed significant differences except for UPD and UPD-PP (p <0,004). In conclusion, external devices like Prime Protector could help decrease aerosol diffusion during high-speed handpiece activation. However, this dome does not replace the use of PPE inside dental clinics.
建议使用外部圆顶气溶胶容纳装置(Prime Protector)来减少牙科诊所内颗粒的传播。因此,我们的研究目的是通过计算生孢梭菌(Lactobacillus casei Shirota)的菌落形成单位(CFU),比较在有和没有 Prime Protector 圆顶(PP)的情况下,高速手机(HH)和超声洁牙器(UPD)产生的生物气溶胶在 x 和 y 轴上不同距离的扩散情况。PP 是根据圆顶底座与模拟器正面之间的平行度放置的,将口腔中心与圆顶中心对齐。PP 圆顶的尺寸为 560.0mm x 255.0mm x 5mm。培养皿分别放置在 0.5m、1m 和 1.5m 处。在实验室环境中进行了三次气溶胶生成实验,实验分组如下:1)HH,2)HH-PP,3)UPD,4)UPD-PP。每个牙科设备激活(HH 和 UPD)在牙科仿体的上前牙上有 2 分钟的时间框架,使用含有生孢梭菌(YAKULT 0836A 0123;1027F 0407)的液体悬浮液。空气压力和通风参数化。未单独使用高容量抽吸,也未在圆顶上附加空气去除装置。结果显示 CFU 计数在距离和轴之间没有显著差异。当对每个装置和距离的平均值进行比较时,除 UPD 和 UPD-PP 之间(p <0.004)外,所有装置和距离之间都有显著差异。结论:外部设备如 Prime Protector 可以帮助减少高速手机激活时气溶胶的扩散。然而,这个圆顶并不能替代牙科诊所内个人防护设备的使用。