Ishani Ganguli (
Maia L. Crawford, Dartmouth College, Lebanon, New Hampshire.
Health Aff (Millwood). 2023 Aug;42(8):1128-1139. doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2022.01319.
Policy makers and payers increasingly hold health systems accountable for spending and quality for their attributed beneficiaries. Low-value care-medical services that offer little or no benefit and have the potential for harm in specific clinical scenarios-received outside of these systems could threaten success on both fronts. Using national Medicare data for fee-for-service beneficiaries ages sixty-five and older and attributed to 595 US health systems, we describe where and from whom they received forty low-value services during 2017-18 and identify factors associated with out-of-system receipt. Forty-three percent of low-value services received by attributed beneficiaries originated from out-of-system clinicians: 38 percent from specialists, 4 percent from primary care physicians, and 1 percent from advanced practice clinicians. Recipients of low-value care were more likely to obtain that care out of system if age 75 or older (versus ages 65-74), male (versus female), non-Hispanic White (versus other races or ethnicities), rural dwelling (versus metropolitan dwelling), more medically complex, or experiencing lower continuity of care. However, out-of-system service receipt was not associated with recipients' health systems' accountable care organization status. Health systems might improve quality and reduce spending for their attributed beneficiaries by addressing out-of-system receipt of low-value care-for example, by improving continuity.
政策制定者和支付方越来越多地要求医疗体系对其所属受益人的支出和质量负责。低价值的医疗服务在特定临床情况下几乎或根本没有益处,但有可能造成伤害,如果这些服务在这些体系之外提供,可能会对这两方面的成功构成威胁。我们使用了全国医疗保险按服务收费受益人的数据,这些受益人为 65 岁及以上的老年人,归属于 595 个美国医疗体系,描述了他们在 2017-18 年期间在何处以及从何处获得了四十种低价值服务,并确定了与体系外获得服务相关的因素。在归属于医疗体系的受益人群中,有 43%的低价值服务来自体系外的医生:38%来自专科医生,4%来自初级保健医生,1%来自高级执业医生。如果患者年龄在 75 岁或以上(而不是 65-74 岁)、男性(而不是女性)、非西班牙裔白人(而不是其他种族或族裔)、居住在农村(而不是大都市)、病情更复杂或医疗连续性较低,他们更有可能从体系外获得低价值的医疗服务。然而,体系外服务的获得与患者的医疗体系是否为问责制医疗组织无关。医疗体系可以通过解决低价值医疗服务的体系外获得问题,例如通过提高连续性,来提高所属受益人的服务质量并降低支出。