支持已批准《联合国残疾人权利公约》国家中存在沟通障碍和沟通差异的人群的沟通渠道:一项综合综述。
Supporting Communication Access of People With Communication Disabilities and Communication Differences in UNCRPD-Ratified Countries: An Integrative Review.
作者信息
Kearns Áine, Jagoe Caroline, Stockdale Rachael, Clarke Dorothy, Manning Molly, Menamin Ruth Mc, Fitzmaurice Yvonne, Green James, Duffy Orla, Kelly Helen
机构信息
School of Allied Health, University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland.
Health Research Institute, University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland.
出版信息
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2025 Sep-Oct;60(5):e70098. doi: 10.1111/1460-6984.70098.
BACKGROUND
The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD) recognizes communication accessibility as a fundamental human right. Communication plays a key role in facilitating belonging, sharing and engaging with communities, allowing individuals to connect and forge relationships. Communication is fundamental to well-being and building a sense of self and identity, as well as establishing and maintaining social roles and vocation. Those with communication disabilities or differences can face many barriers to social participation, inclusion and potential financial implications.
AIMS
This integrative review explores policy, practices and guidelines that support communication access of adults with communication disabilities and differences in selected English-speaking countries with UNCRPD-ratified status and well-established speech and language therapy services.
METHODS
An integrative review of the literature was undertaken. A systematic search of the published, peer-reviewed literature was conducted for empirical research, and a manual search was undertaken to obtain policy, practice, or guidelines, to support communication access at a sectoral/service or community level. A multi-scalar approach situates the findings within several contexts: international law, national legislation and policy, professional guidelines and evidence from local/national projects.
MAIN CONTRIBUTIONS
A multi-scalar map was developed that positions the findings on communication access within the included countries (Republic of Ireland, Northern Ireland, United Kingdom, Canada, Australia and New Zealand), across local/national programmes and projects (n = 11), professional body and civil society guidance, regional/national legislation and policy specific to communication access and finally the international normative instrument of the UNCRPD. The findings indicate that communication accessibility is recognised as a fundamental human right, but signatory states are required to take appropriate measures to ensure access to information and communication for persons with disabilities. National legislation, policy and practice need further scrutiny in this regard.
CONCLUSIONS
This review examines the complex phenomenon of communication access for people with communication disabilities and differences. The findings of this review can inform and shape practice with regard to communication accessibility as well as support advocacy efforts and future research in this area.
WHAT THIS PAPER ADDS
What is already known on the subject Communication accessibility is a fundamental human right. It can be characterized by the respectful and responsive treatment of individuals with communication disabilities and differences, along with the implementation of strategies and resources and the adaptation of environments, process and systems to facilitate effective communication. What this paper adds to existing knowledge A multi-scalar map was developed that situates the findings on communication access within the included countries (Republic of Ireland, Northern Ireland, United Kingdom, Canada, Australia and New Zealand), across local/national programmes and projects (n = 11), professional body and civil society guidance, regional/national legislation and policies specific to communication access, and finally the international normative instrument of the UNCRPD. There is a lack of a shared understanding of communication access within empirical research, policy and local and national guidelines across the included countries. In addition, the focus on the right to communication is addressed more explicitly in some groups (and country contexts) than others. What are the practical and clinical implications of this work? This review highlights how multimodal communication is important for accessible communication. Co-design can also be harnessed to enhance communication access. The review provides an integrated set of data (empirical research, policy and guidelines) that can be used in future research, practice development and advocacy.
背景
《联合国残疾人权利公约》(UNCRPD)承认沟通无障碍是一项基本人权。沟通在促进归属感、共享以及参与社区活动方面发挥着关键作用,使个人能够建立联系并形成人际关系。沟通对于幸福感、塑造自我意识和身份认同,以及确立和维持社会角色及职业至关重要。有沟通障碍或差异的人在社会参与、融入以及可能面临的经济影响方面会遇到诸多障碍。
目的
本整合性综述探讨了在已批准《联合国残疾人权利公约》且拥有成熟言语和语言治疗服务的选定英语国家中,支持有沟通障碍和差异的成年人实现沟通无障碍的政策、实践和指南。
方法
对文献进行了整合性综述。对已发表的、经过同行评审的文献进行系统检索以获取实证研究,并进行人工检索以获取在部门/服务或社区层面支持沟通无障碍的政策、实践或指南。采用多尺度方法将研究结果置于多个背景下:国际法、国家立法和政策、专业指南以及来自地方/国家项目的证据。
主要贡献
绘制了一幅多尺度地图,将在所纳入国家(爱尔兰共和国、北爱尔兰、英国、加拿大、澳大利亚和新西兰)内关于沟通无障碍的研究结果,置于地方/国家项目和计划(n = 11)、专业团体和民间社会指导、特定于沟通无障碍的区域/国家立法和政策以及最终的《联合国残疾人权利公约》这一国际规范性文书之中。研究结果表明,沟通无障碍被视为一项基本人权,但签署国需要采取适当措施以确保残疾人能够获取信息和进行沟通。在这方面,国家立法、政策和实践需要进一步审视。
结论
本综述审视了有沟通障碍和差异的人实现沟通无障碍这一复杂现象。本综述的研究结果可为沟通无障碍方面的实践提供参考并塑造实践方式,同时支持该领域的宣传工作和未来研究。
本文补充内容
关于该主题已知的信息 沟通无障碍是一项基本人权。其特点可以是对有沟通障碍和差异的个人给予尊重和积极回应的对待,同时实施策略和资源,并对环境、流程和系统进行调整以促进有效沟通。本文对现有知识的补充 绘制了一幅多尺度地图,将在所纳入国家(爱尔兰共和国、北爱尔兰、英国、加拿大、澳大利亚和新西兰)内关于沟通无障碍的研究结果,置于地方/国家项目和计划(n = 11)、专业团体和民间社会指导、特定于沟通无障碍的区域/国家立法和政策以及最终的《联合国残疾人权利公约》这一国际规范性文书之中。在所纳入国家的实证研究、政策以及地方和国家指南中,对于沟通无障碍缺乏共同的理解。此外,在某些群体(以及国家背景)中,对沟通权的关注比其他群体更为明确。这项工作的实际和临床意义是什么?本综述强调了多模式沟通对于无障碍沟通的重要性。协同设计也可用于增强沟通无障碍。本综述提供了一套综合数据(实证研究、政策和指南),可用于未来研究、实践发展和宣传工作。
相似文献
Health Soc Care Deliv Res. 2025-5-21
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2022-9
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2014-4-29
Autism Adulthood. 2024-12-2
Autism Adulthood. 2024-12-2
本文引用的文献
Neuropsychol Rehabil. 2025-6
Rev Esp Sanid Penit. 2023
Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2024-3
Int J Speech Lang Pathol. 2023-2
Int J Speech Lang Pathol. 2022-10