Iscte-Instituto Universitário de Lisboa, CIS-Iscte, Lisboa, Portugal.
Research Center for Psychological Science, Faculdade de Psicologia, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal.
Behav Res Methods. 2024 Apr;56(4):4009-4018. doi: 10.3758/s13428-023-02196-0. Epub 2023 Aug 8.
Sentence processing is affected by the sentence context and word expectancy. To investigate sentence comprehension experimentally, it is useful to have sentence completion norms with both context constraint and word expectancy measures. In this study, two experiments were conducted to collect norms for completion of 807 European Portuguese sentences. Context constraint was measured through type-token ratio and proportion idiosyncratic responses, while word expectancy was assessed by cloze probability. Besides establishing norms for a large sample of sentences, the study investigated the impact of the production procedure and method of analysis. In Experiment 1, a single-production procedure was used, i.e., participants completed each sentence fragment with only a single response, whereas in Experiment 2, a multiple-production procedure was used, i.e., participants have to provide up to three completion words for each sentence fragment. In Experiment 2, the analyses were obtained using two distinct methods: first-response analysis and combined-response analysis. The results showed that cloze and context measures are comparable between production paradigms and that the results from both analysis methods were correlated. The advantages of each production procedure and analysis method are discussed.
句子处理受到句子语境和单词预期的影响。为了在实验中研究句子理解,使用具有语境约束和单词预期测量的句子完成规范是很有用的。在这项研究中,进行了两项实验来收集 807 个欧洲葡萄牙语句子完成的规范。语境约束通过类型 - 令牌比和比例独特反应来测量,而单词预期则通过 cloze 概率来评估。除了为大量句子建立规范外,该研究还调查了生产过程和分析方法的影响。在实验 1 中,使用了单一生产过程,即参与者只用一个单一的反应来完成每个句子片段,而在实验 2 中,使用了多个生产过程,即参与者必须为每个句子片段提供多达三个完成词。在实验 2 中,使用了两种不同的分析方法来获得分析结果:首次响应分析和组合响应分析。结果表明,在生产范式之间 cloze 和语境测量是可比的,并且两种分析方法的结果是相关的。讨论了每种生产过程和分析方法的优点。