Mitra Ruchi, Rai Arpita, Kumar Ansul, Mitra Jeewan Kumar
Department of Dentistry, Phulo Jhano Government Medical College and Hospital, Dumka, Jharkhand, India.
Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, Rajendra Institute of Medical Sciences, Ranchi, Jharkhand, India.
Addict Health. 2023 Jan;15(1):63-70. doi: 10.34172/ahj.2023.1290. Epub 2023 Jan 29.
Literature reports randomized trials have examined herbal drugs and other smoking cessation therapies such as aromatherapy acupuncture but no comprehensive overview of the overall results has been provided. The present systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to describe the overall effectiveness and safety of herbal medicines.
This study was conducted from December 2020 to April 2021 by searching seven databases. Herbal drugs have been shown to help people quit smoking in randomized controlled studies. Two teams of researchers independently extracted the data.
A total of 12 trials with 762 smokers were included in this study. The heterogeneity I was 43.6% with =0.03 (Cochrane Q test) and χ=15.77. The overall odds ratio (OR) at 95% confidence interval (CI) was 0.91 (0.68- 1.20) which shows a protective factor of herbal preparations and very low heterogeneity. The herbal treatments such as , St. John's Wort, and lavender essential oil were significantly related to a higher continuous abstinence rate (CAR) compared to the controls with risk ratio (RR): 2.13 (0.57-4.61) at week 8; RR: 2.72 (0.77-5.3) at week 12; and RR: 2.77 (0.37-1.13) at week 24. A 7-day point abstinence rate (PAR) at week 8 was RR: 1.24 (0.81-6.34) with 95% CI; RR: 2.09 (0.93-8.29) at week 12, and RR: 2.11 (0.3-3.08) at week 24. Black pepper and lime were better in craving reduction than the placebo group. This study found no significant difference between the treatment and control groups in adverse effects, despite some minor side effects with herbal drugs.
The results of this study showed herbal treatments have the potential to help smokers quit the habit. Further well-designed trials comparing standardized herbal medicines with conventional therapy and placebo are recommended to reinforce this data.
文献报道随机试验已对草药及其他戒烟疗法如芳香疗法、针灸进行了研究,但尚未对总体结果进行全面概述。本系统评价和荟萃分析旨在描述草药的总体有效性和安全性。
本研究于2020年12月至2021年4月通过检索七个数据库进行。在随机对照研究中,草药已被证明有助于人们戒烟。两组研究人员独立提取数据。
本研究共纳入12项试验,涉及762名吸烟者。异质性I为43.6%,P = 0.03(Cochrane Q检验),χ² = 15.77。95%置信区间(CI)的总体比值比(OR)为0.91(0.68 - 1.20),表明草药制剂有保护作用且异质性非常低。与对照组相比,圣约翰草、薰衣草精油等草药治疗与更高的持续戒烟率(CAR)显著相关,第8周风险比(RR):2.13(0.57 - 4.61);第12周RR:2.72(0.77 - 5.3);第24周RR:2.77(0.37 - 1.13)。第8周7天点戒烟率(PAR)的RR为1.24(0.81 - 6.34),95%CI;第12周RR:2.09(0.93 - 8.29);第24周RR:2.11(0.3 - 3.08)。黑胡椒和酸橙在减少烟瘾方面比安慰剂组更好。尽管草药有一些轻微副作用,但本研究发现治疗组和对照组在不良反应方面无显著差异。
本研究结果表明草药治疗有帮助吸烟者戒烟的潜力。建议进一步开展设计良好的试验,将标准化草药与传统疗法及安慰剂进行比较,以加强这一数据。