Biology Department, Skidmore College, Saratoga Springs, New York, United States of America.
Center for Teaching Excellence, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2023 Aug 10;18(8):e0289680. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0289680. eCollection 2023.
The present study investigates the impact of explicit, reflective Nature of Science instruction on students' evolution acceptance, understanding of evolution as a theory, and understanding of Nature of Science in an introductory biology course. Results revealed similar improvement in evolution acceptance in both the treatment and control groups, but also that Nature of Science instruction had disproportionately large impacts on evolution acceptance for women and individuals who already had high acceptance. We also found evidence of relationships between understanding and acceptance of evolution and Nature of Science understanding, particularly the creativity aspect of Nature of Science. Together, these results suggest that targeted Nature of Science instruction can have differential impacts on students with particular characteristics, such as women and individuals with high acceptance, but also point to the need to consider additional interventions that can reach men and individuals with low acceptance.
本研究探讨了显性、反思性的科学本质教学对学生在一门生物学入门课程中对进化的接受程度、对进化作为一种理论的理解以及对科学本质的理解的影响。结果显示,在实验组和对照组中,学生对进化的接受程度都有类似的提高,但科学本质教学对女性和已经高度接受进化的个体的进化接受程度的影响不成比例地大。我们还发现,对进化和科学本质理解的理解与接受之间存在关系,特别是科学本质的创造性方面。这些结果表明,有针对性的科学本质教学可能对具有特定特征的学生产生不同的影响,例如女性和高度接受进化的个体,但也指出需要考虑其他干预措施,以覆盖男性和接受程度低的个体。