Kirmess Melanie, Guttormsen Linn Stokke, Hofslundsengen Hilde, Næss Kari-Anne Bottegaard, Kefalianos Elaina
Department of Special Needs Education, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway,.
Department of Special Needs Education, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway,; Department of Early Childhood Education, Oslo Metropolitan University Oslo, Norway.
J Fluency Disord. 2023 Sep;77:105999. doi: 10.1016/j.jfludis.2023.105999. Epub 2023 Aug 5.
This study investigated the treatment practices of speech-language pathologists (SLPs) with preschool children who stutter to explore variations in service delivery and, consequently to better inform and support evidence-based practice.
121 Norwegian SLPs completed an online survey about stuttering treatment for preschool children aged up to six years. They reported on treatment training, choices, setting, dosage, and outcomes. Data was analysed descriptively. Correlation analyses between years of clinical experience and clinician perceived outcomes were conducted.
Sixty-eight percent of SLPs were trained in one or more stuttering treatment programs. The majority of SLPs (83 %) provided treatment in person in preschool centers; 59 % reported providing treatment once a week. Thirty-four percent of SLPs reported that they often or always delivered the whole treatment program. Treatment practice addressed various elements, including advising parents about language and communication strategies, supporting the child's self-image, and perceived outcomes. The SLPs reported their clinician perceived outcomes as 'always' or 'often' reduction of audible stuttering (70 %), reduced cognitive and emotional reactions (55 %), and improved communication skills (58 %). Factors influencing treatment choices were identified at the systemic level (e.g., work place regulations) and individual level (e.g., SLPs competency, child's best).
Stuttering treatment services in Norway differ from those reported in existing literature as treatment is given in preschool settings, only 34 % of SLPs deliver programs as intended whilst the majority use treatment elements only, and still experience positive changes. Provision is variable, and seems influenced by SLP training and competence.
本研究调查了言语语言病理学家(SLP)对学龄前口吃儿童的治疗实践,以探索服务提供方面的差异,从而更好地为循证实践提供信息并给予支持。
121名挪威言语语言病理学家完成了一项关于6岁及以下学龄前儿童口吃治疗的在线调查。他们报告了治疗培训、选择、环境、剂量和结果。对数据进行了描述性分析。对临床经验年限与临床医生感知到的结果之间进行了相关性分析。
68%的言语语言病理学家接受过一种或多种口吃治疗方案的培训。大多数言语语言病理学家(83%)在学前中心亲自提供治疗;59%的人报告每周提供一次治疗。34%的言语语言病理学家报告说他们经常或总是实施整个治疗方案。治疗实践涉及多个方面,包括就语言和沟通策略向家长提供建议、支持儿童的自我形象以及感知到其结果。言语语言病理学家报告他们临床医生感知到的结果为“总是”或“经常”可闻性口吃减少(70%)、认知和情绪反应减少(55%)以及沟通技能提高(58%)。在系统层面(如工作场所规定)和个人层面(如言语语言病理学家的能力、儿童的最佳利益)确定了影响治疗选择的因素。
挪威的口吃治疗服务与现有文献中报道的不同,因为治疗是在学前环境中进行的,只有34%的言语语言病理学家按预期实施治疗方案,而大多数仅使用治疗要素,但仍取得了积极变化。服务提供存在差异,似乎受言语语言病理学家的培训和能力影响。