Department of Public Health, McCann Healthcare Worldwide Japan Inc., Tokyo, Japan.
Department of Research, Down to Earth Inc., Tokyo, Japan.
Am J Health Promot. 2023 Nov;37(8):1162-1170. doi: 10.1177/08901171231193783. Epub 2023 Aug 11.
This review comprehensively examines interventions which sought to improve the occupational safety and/or health of construction workers. Factors that explain the (in)effectiveness of interventions were also summarized.
This review consisted of a search using two electronic databases, PubMed and Web of Science.
Targeted workers in the construction industry; had at least one primary outcome that aimed to improve occupational safety and/or health; were published between January 01, 1990 and December 01, 2019; and were written in English.
Two researchers independently carried out the process of reviewing the titles, abstracts and full texts, and extracted all data. If there were differences, discussions were held until a consensus was reached.
A total of 1297 articles were retrieved and 24 were selected for final evaluation. Seventeen studies reported significant intervention effects, while 7 found their primary outcome not significantly improved.
Future research should place more effort on interventions aimed at improving both occupational safety and health outcomes in an integrated manner, with environmental interventions that accompany behavioral interventions at the individual level. Besides, additional effort is also needed to ensure the involvement of relevant stakeholders in designing the intervention, avoiding contamination effects (through cluster randomization), optimizing the "dosage" of intervention, and improving measurement of outcomes.
本综述全面考察了旨在改善建筑工人职业安全和/或健康的干预措施。还总结了解释干预措施(有效/无效)的因素。
本综述包括对两个电子数据库 PubMed 和 Web of Science 的搜索。
目标人群为建筑行业工人;至少有一个旨在改善职业安全和/或健康的主要结局;发表于 1990 年 1 月 1 日至 2019 年 12 月 1 日之间;并以英文撰写。
两名研究人员独立进行了审查标题、摘要和全文的过程,并提取了所有数据。如果存在分歧,则进行讨论,直到达成共识。
共检索到 1297 篇文章,最终有 24 篇被选入进行评估。17 项研究报告了干预措施的显著效果,而 7 项研究发现其主要结局没有显著改善。
未来的研究应更加努力地开展旨在综合改善职业安全和健康结果的干预措施,同时在个体层面上开展环境干预措施以配合行为干预措施。此外,还需要额外努力确保相关利益攸关方参与设计干预措施,避免污染效应(通过整群随机化),优化干预措施的“剂量”,并改进结局测量。