Department of Social Work and Social Administration, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong.
Fam Process. 2024 Sep;63(3):1446-1468. doi: 10.1111/famp.12923. Epub 2023 Aug 13.
Research has focused on intimate partner violence (IPV) against women either before or after separation, but little attention has been paid to the changes in and persistence of violent behaviors from one situation to the next. This study contributes to the literature by comparing the changes in types and frequencies of abusive behaviors of women's former husbands. This allows us to understand how mechanisms of power are enacted through IPV both before and after separation. We interviewed 19 women in the Midwestern United States who had experienced IPV by their former husbands and had subsequently divorced them. Data were analyzed using qualitative content analysis. The findings suggest that verbal abuse and using children were the most common forms of IPV both pre- and postseparation. Many preseparation behaviors were replaced by other forms of abuse; for example, physical abuse was not experienced after separation. Some forms of IPV, such as stalking and economic abuse, escalated after separation. This reveals that exerting control over women through nonphysical forms of IPV was more common after separation. In particular, using axial and selective coding approach, our findings present three composite narratives of women's experiences of the changes in, and the escalation and persistence of, the violence they faced. The three composite narratives show how abusive behaviors are situated within patriarchal notions of dominance, power, and control over women and their children. The implications of the findings are discussed in terms of healthcare services, advocacy-based victim assistance, school officials, and the courts.
研究主要集中在女性在分居前后遭受的亲密伴侣暴力(IPV)上,但很少关注暴力行为从一种情况到另一种情况的变化和持续。本研究通过比较女性前夫的虐待行为的类型和频率的变化,为文献做出了贡献。这使我们能够了解权力机制如何通过 IPV 在分居前后发挥作用。我们采访了 19 名来自美国中西部的女性,她们曾遭受过前夫的 IPV 并与之离婚。数据使用定性内容分析进行分析。研究结果表明,言语虐待和利用子女是分居前后最常见的 IPV 形式。许多分居前的行为被其他形式的虐待所取代;例如,分居后没有经历过身体虐待。一些形式的 IPV,如跟踪和经济虐待,在分居后升级。这表明,通过非身体形式的 IPV 对女性施加控制在分居后更为常见。特别是,通过轴向和选择性编码方法,我们的研究结果提出了女性经历暴力变化、升级和持续的三个综合叙述,她们所面临的暴力。这三个综合叙述展示了虐待行为如何在父权制观念中处于主导地位、权力和对妇女及其子女的控制之下。研究结果从医疗保健服务、基于宣传的受害者援助、学校官员和法院等方面进行了讨论。