Department of Neurology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Centre for Community Medicine, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Int J Stroke. 2024 Jan;19(1):76-83. doi: 10.1177/17474930231189395. Epub 2023 Aug 14.
India accounts for 13.3% of global disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) lost due to stroke with a relatively younger age of onset compared to the Western population. In India's public healthcare system, many stroke patients seek care at tertiary-level government-funded medical colleges where an optimal level of stroke care is expected. However, there are no studies from India that have assessed the quality of stroke care, including infrastructure, imaging facilities, or the availability of stroke care units in medical colleges.
This study aimed to understand the existing protocols and management of acute stroke care across 22 medical colleges in India, as part of the baseline assessment of the ongoing IMPETUS stroke study.
A semi-structured quantitative pre-tested questionnaire, developed based on review of literature and expert discussion, was mailed to 22 participating sites of the IMPETUS stroke study. The questionnaire assessed comprehensively all components of stroke care, including human resources, emergency system, in-hospital care, and secondary prevention. A descriptive analysis of their status was undertaken.
In the emergency services, limited stroke helpline numbers, 3/22 (14%); prenotification system, 5/22 (23%); and stroke-trained physicians were available, 6/22 (27%). One-third of hospitals did not have on-call neurologists. Although non-contrast computed tomography (NCCT) was always available, 39% of hospitals were not doing computed tomography (CT) angiography and 13/22 (59%) were not doing magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) after routine working hours. Intravenous thrombolysis was being done in 20/22 (91%) hospitals, but 36% of hospitals did not provide it free of cost. Endovascular therapy was available only in 6/22 (27%) hospitals. The study highlighted the scarcity of multidisciplinary stroke teams, 8/22 (36%), and stroke units, 7/22 (32%). Lifesaving surgeries like hematoma evacuation, 11/22 (50%), and decompressive craniectomy, 9/22 (41%), were performed in limited numbers. The availability of occupational therapists, speech therapists, and cognitive rehabilitation was minimal.
This study highlighted the current status of acute stroke management in publicly funded tertiary care hospitals. Lack of prenotification, limited number of stroke-trained physicians and neurosurgeons, relatively lesser provision of free thrombolytic agents, limited stroke units, and lack of rehabilitation services are areas needing urgent attention by policymakers and creation of sustainable education models for uniform stroke care by medical professionals across the country.
印度因中风而导致的伤残调整生命年(DALYs)占全球的 13.3%,其发病年龄比西方人口更为年轻。在印度的公共医疗体系中,许多中风患者在政府资助的三级医学院寻求治疗,而这些医学院理应提供最佳的中风治疗水平。然而,印度目前还没有评估医学院中风治疗质量的研究,包括基础设施、影像设备或中风治疗单元的可用性。
本研究旨在了解印度 22 所医学院急性中风治疗的现有方案和管理,作为正在进行的 IMPETUS 中风研究的基线评估的一部分。
我们向 IMPETUS 中风研究的 22 个参与地点邮寄了一份半结构化的定量预测试问卷,该问卷是根据文献回顾和专家讨论制定的。该问卷全面评估了中风治疗的所有组成部分,包括人力资源、急救系统、院内治疗和二级预防。我们对其现状进行了描述性分析。
在急救服务方面,仅有 14%(22 家医院中的 3 家)的医院提供中风急救热线,23%(22 家医院中的 5 家)的医院提供预先通知系统,27%(22 家医院中的 6 家)的医院配备了经过中风培训的医生。三分之一的医院没有随叫随到的神经科医生。虽然所有医院都可以进行非对比增强计算机断层扫描(NCCT),但仍有 39%的医院不进行计算机断层血管造影(CTA),13/22(59%)的医院在常规工作时间之外不进行磁共振成像(MRI)检查。22 家医院中有 20 家(91%)可以进行静脉溶栓治疗,但有 36%的医院不免费提供。血管内治疗仅在 6 家(27%)医院提供。该研究还强调了中风多学科治疗团队(36%,22 家医院中的 8 家)和中风单元(32%,22 家医院中的 7 家)的稀缺性。仅 50%(22 家医院中的 11 家)的医院进行了血肿清除术等救命手术,41%(22 家医院中的 9 家)的医院进行了减压性颅骨切除术。作业治疗师、言语治疗师和认知康复治疗师的数量非常有限。
本研究强调了公共资助的三级护理医院中急性中风管理的现状。缺乏预先通知、经过中风培训的医生和神经外科医生数量有限、免费溶栓药物的提供相对较少、中风单元数量有限以及康复服务的缺乏,这些都是政策制定者急需关注的问题,需要为全国的医疗专业人员制定可持续的教育模式,以实现统一的中风治疗。