Szpunar Monika, Johnson Andrew M, Driediger Molly, Tucker Patricia
Health and Rehabilitation Sciences Program, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Western Ontario, London, ON N6A 3K7, Canada.
School of Health Studies, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Western Ontario, London, ON N6A 3K7, Canada.
Children (Basel). 2023 Aug 4;10(8):1346. doi: 10.3390/children10081346.
Children's outdoor risky play is important for healthy development. However, Early Childhood Educators (ECEs) concern for child safety often restricts risky play affordances during childcare. To reduce this trend, an Outdoor Play Risk Re-Framing workshop was delivered to ECEs in London, Ontario, and the immediate/short-term impact of the workshop on ECEs' knowledge, self-efficacy, and risk tolerance for engaging children in outdoor risky play was examined. Via a natural experiment, using a quasi-experimental design, ECEs in the experimental group ( = 119) completed an Outdoor Play Risk Re-Framing workshop, while ECEs in the comparison group ( = 51) continued their typical curriculum. All ECEs completed the same survey assessing their knowledge ( = 11 items), self-efficacy ( = 15 items), and risk tolerance ( = 27 items) at baseline and 1-week post-intervention. A maximum likelihood linear mixed effects model was conducted, while deductive content analysis was used for open-ended items. The workshop intervention resulted in significant improvements in ECEs' self-efficacy ( = 0.001); however, no significant changes were observed for knowledge (i.e., awareness and practices; = 0.01 and = 0.49, respectively) or risk tolerance ( = 0.20). Qualitative data revealed similar findings across both groups, highlighting physical development as a benefit to outdoor risky play and fear of liability as a barrier. In conclusion, providing ECEs with an Outdoor Play Risk Re-Framing workshop shows promise for supporting their self-efficacy to promote this behavior but does not impact ECEs' knowledge or risk tolerance to lead outdoor risky play.
儿童户外冒险游戏对其健康发展至关重要。然而,幼儿教育工作者(ECEs)对儿童安全的担忧常常限制了在儿童保育期间的冒险游戏机会。为了减少这种趋势,在安大略省伦敦市为幼儿教育工作者举办了一次户外游戏风险重新界定研讨会,并考察了该研讨会对幼儿教育工作者让儿童参与户外冒险游戏的知识、自我效能感和风险承受能力的即时/短期影响。通过一项自然实验,采用准实验设计,实验组(n = 119)的幼儿教育工作者完成了一次户外游戏风险重新界定研讨会,而对照组(n = 51)的幼儿教育工作者继续他们的常规课程。所有幼儿教育工作者在基线和干预后1周完成了相同的调查,评估他们的知识(n = 11项)、自我效能感(n = 15项)和风险承受能力(n = 27项)。进行了最大似然线性混合效应模型分析,同时对开放式项目采用了演绎性内容分析。研讨会干预使幼儿教育工作者的自我效能感有了显著提高(p = 0.001);然而,在知识方面(即认知和实践;分别为p = 0.01和p = 0.49)或风险承受能力方面(p = 0.20)未观察到显著变化。定性数据在两组中显示出类似的结果,突出了身体发育是户外冒险游戏的一个益处,而对责任的担忧是一个障碍。总之,为幼儿教育工作者提供户外游戏风险重新界定研讨会有望支持他们促进这种行为的自我效能感,但不会影响幼儿教育工作者开展户外冒险游戏的知识或风险承受能力。