Huang Austin, Zhu Harrison, Zhou Kelvin, Kirby R Parker, Dasari Nina, Calderara Gianmarco A, Cordova Kathryn, Sorensen Ryan, Bhatnagar Anshul, Kim Soo Jung
Department of Dermatology, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX, United States.
JMIR Dermatol. 2022 Sep 12;5(3):e39201. doi: 10.2196/39201.
The Altmetric score (AS) is a novel measure of publication impact that is calculated by the number of mentions across various social media websites. This method may have advantages over traditional bibliometrics in the context of research by medical students.
This study aimed to determine whether dermatology matriculants who graduated from higher-ranked medical schools published more articles with greater impact (ie, a higher AS) than those from lower-ranked institutions.
A PubMed search for articles published by dermatology residents who started medical school in 2020 was conducted. Demographic information and Altmetric data were collected, and medical schools were sorted according to US News' top-25 and non-top-25 categories.
Residents who completed their medical training at a top-25 institution published more papers (mean 4.93, SD 4.18 vs mean 3.11, SD 3.32; P<.001) and accrued a significantly higher total AS (mean 67.9, SD 160 vs mean 22.9, SD 75.9; P<.001) and average AS (mean 13.1, SD 23.7 vs mean 6.71, SD 32.3; P<.001) per article than those who graduated from non-top-25 schools.
Our results indicate that students in top-25 schools may have greater access to research resources and opportunities. With a pass/fail United States Medical Licensing Examination Step 1 exam that may increasingly shift focus toward scholarly output from medical students, further discussion on how to create a more equitable dermatology match is essential.
Altmetric评分(AS)是一种衡量出版物影响力的新方法,通过各种社交媒体网站上的提及次数来计算。在医学生的研究背景下,这种方法可能比传统的文献计量学具有优势。
本研究旨在确定毕业于排名较高医学院校的皮肤科新生是否比排名较低院校的学生发表了更多具有更大影响力(即更高的AS)的文章。
对2020年开始医学院学习的皮肤科住院医师发表的文章进行PubMed检索。收集人口统计学信息和Altmetric数据,并根据《美国新闻与世界报道》的前25名和非前25名类别对医学院校进行分类。
在排名前25的机构完成医学培训的住院医师发表的论文更多(平均4.93篇,标准差4.18篇对平均3.11篇,标准差3.32篇;P<0.001),每篇文章的总AS(平均67.9,标准差160对平均22.9,标准差75.9;P<0.001)和平均AS(平均13.1,标准差23.7对平均6.71,标准差32.3;P<0.001)显著高于毕业于非前25名学校的住院医师。
我们的结果表明,排名前25的学校的学生可能有更多机会获得研究资源和机会。随着美国医师执照考试第一步采用通过/失败制,可能会越来越多地将重点转向医学生的学术产出,因此有必要进一步讨论如何创建更公平的皮肤科匹配。