Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust, UK.
Manchester Academic Health Sciences Centre, University of Manchester, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2024 Apr;106(4):359-363. doi: 10.1308/rcsann.2023.0056. Epub 2023 Aug 29.
There has been an almost 100% increase in referrals to breast cancer diagnostic clinics in the past decade. Breaching of the two-week cancer referral target is now commonplace, potentially delaying diagnoses of breast malignancy in many women. Almost one in five of these referrals are women with mastalgia, not a symptom linked to breast cancer. The objective of the study was the safe introduction of an advanced nurse practitioner-led telephone service for women with mastalgia to improve the service for women and create capacity for those with "red flag" breast symptoms.
Referrals to clinic were triaged, women with mastalgia only were directed to a telephone-based assessment clinic and symptoms evaluated using a multidisciplinary created proforma.
Within 23 months, 1,427 women were assessed in the breast pain telephone assessment clinic: 863 (61%) were aged over 40 and 564 (39%) aged under 40. A total of 1,238 underwent telephone assessment. Reassurance and discharge only was needed for 365 (26%). The aetiology of pain was identified as musculoskeletal in 1,104/1,238 (89%) of patients, with only 39/1,238 (3.2%) identified as having true breast pain. Additional symptoms were mentioned by 264 women (18%) during the consultation; all immediately redirected back to a diagnostic clinic. Mammography was undertaken in 609 women (43%). Seven women (0.6%) were diagnosed with a breast malignancy. Patient survey indicated that 93% of patients were satisfied with the care received and 97% said they would recommend the service to a family member or friend.
Although face-to-face assessments for breast pain remain the standard practice in many breast units, data indicating the safety of a telephone assessment clinic, along with high levels of patient satisfaction, question whether services can be delivered differently.
在过去十年中,前往乳腺癌诊断诊所的转诊量增加了近 100%。现在,违反两周内转诊癌症的目标已成家常便饭,这可能导致许多女性的乳腺癌恶性肿瘤诊断被延误。这些转诊中几乎有五分之一是乳房痛的女性,而乳房痛并非与乳腺癌相关的症状。该研究的目的是安全引入由高级执业护师主导的电话服务,以改善乳房痛女性的服务,并为那些有“红色警报”乳房症状的患者创造容量。
对转诊进行分类,仅将乳房痛的女性转至基于电话的评估诊所,并使用多学科创建的表格评估症状。
在 23 个月内,有 1427 名女性在乳房疼痛电话评估诊所接受了评估:863 名(61%)年龄超过 40 岁,564 名(39%)年龄在 40 岁以下。共有 1238 名女性接受了电话评估。仅 365 名(26%)需要进行安抚和直接离院。1238 名患者中,1104 名(89%)的疼痛病因被确定为肌肉骨骼,只有 39 名(3.2%)被确定为真正的乳房疼痛。在咨询过程中,有 264 名女性(18%)提到了其他症状;所有患者都立即被重新引导至诊断诊所。对 609 名女性(43%)进行了乳房 X 光检查。有 7 名女性(0.6%)被诊断患有乳腺癌。患者调查表明,93%的患者对所接受的护理感到满意,97%的患者表示会向家人或朋友推荐该服务。
尽管许多乳房单位仍采用面对面评估乳房疼痛,但数据表明电话评估诊所是安全的,并且患者满意度很高,这引发了对服务是否可以以不同方式提供的质疑。