Dunston Emily R, Taylor Katrina
Department of Wellness and Movement Sciences, Eastern Washington University, Cheney, WA, USA.
Int J Exerc Sci. 2023 Jun 1;16(5):756-769. doi: 10.70252/FQAV8949. eCollection 2023.
High-intensity interval training (HIIT) is suggested as a public health strategy to increase engagement in, and adherence to, physical activity. However, debate exists regarding the efficacy in inactive individuals.
To determine the physiological and psychological responses to three weeks of supervised and three weeks of unsupervised HIIT or moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT) in previously inactive adults.
Young adults ( = 20; 21.4 ± 2.2 years; 13 females) were randomized to six weeks of HIIT or MICT. Pre- and post-testing included anthropometric measures, an incremental exercise test, and body composition. Psychological outcomes (i.e., perceived competence, self-efficacy, and enjoyment) were assessed at the end of the first, ninth, and eighteenth training sessions. Differences in physiological outcomes were analyzed using repeated measures factorial ANCOVAs. Differences in psychological outcomes were analyzed using repeated measures factorial ANOVAs.
Maximal oxygen consumption (Δ 2.8 ml·kg·min; = .03) and peak power output (Δ 20.2 W; = .01) improved over time with no group differences ( > .05). No changes occurred in body composition or self-efficacy ( ≥ .27). Perceived competence increased with supervised training ( = .01) with no further increases during unsupervised training. There was no difference in enjoyment across supervised training ( = .07), but enjoyment decreased during unsupervised training ( = .003).
Cardiorespiratory fitness improved comparably for HIIT and MICT but with a shorter time commitment for HIIT. Perceived competence increased across supervised training suggesting it may be important to provide support at the beginning of an exercise intervention.
高强度间歇训练(HIIT)被提议作为一种公共卫生策略,以提高对体育活动的参与度和坚持度。然而,对于不活跃个体的效果存在争议。
确定在先前不活跃的成年人中,为期三周的监督式和三周的非监督式HIIT或中等强度持续训练(MICT)所产生的生理和心理反应。
将年轻成年人(n = 20;21.4 ± 2.2岁;13名女性)随机分为为期六周的HIIT或MICT组。测试前和测试后包括人体测量、递增运动测试和身体成分分析。在第一次、第九次和第十八次训练课程结束时评估心理结果(即感知能力、自我效能感和享受程度)。使用重复测量析因协方差分析来分析生理结果的差异。使用重复测量析因方差分析来分析心理结果的差异。
最大摄氧量(Δ2.8 ml·kg·min;p = 0.03)和峰值功率输出(Δ20.2 W;p = 0.01)随时间改善,且无组间差异(p > 0.05)。身体成分或自我效能感无变化(p ≥ 0.27)。感知能力在监督训练期间增加(p = 0.01),在非监督训练期间没有进一步增加。在监督训练期间享受程度没有差异(p = 0.07),但在非监督训练期间享受程度下降(p = 0.003)。
HIIT和MICT在改善心肺功能方面效果相当,但HIIT所需的时间投入更短。在监督训练期间感知能力增加,表明在运动干预开始时提供支持可能很重要。