Research Program on Cognition and Neuromodulation Based Interventions, Department of Psychiatry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Headache & Orofacial Pain Effort (H.O.P.E.), Biologic & Materials Sciences, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Brain Stimul. 2023 Sep-Oct;16(5):1328-1335. doi: 10.1016/j.brs.2023.08.025. Epub 2023 Sep 1.
Few studies have investigated tolerability, blinding, and double-blinding of High-Definition transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (HD-tDCS) at amplitudes above 2 milliamps (mA).
We examined a) tolerability of HD-tDCS during stimulation sessions and b) blinding and double blinding of participants and study team members.
Data from a mixed neurologic sample of 292 older adults were pooled from 3046 HD-tDCS sessions (2329 active; 717 sham). Per electrode amplitudes ranged from 1 mA to 4 mA with total currents up to 10 mA. Participants completed a standardized sensation (tolerability) questionnaire after each session. Participants and study team members stated whether the participant received active or sham stimulation at the end of various sessions. Data were collapsed into the presence/absence of a symptom due to low rates of positive responding and were analyzed for both differences and bioequivalency.
There were no safety-related adverse events. HD-tDCS was well tolerated with mostly no ("none") or "mild" sensations reported across sessions, regardless of active or sham condition and in both stimulation naïve and experienced participants. There were no significant differences in side effects between active and sham, with some achieving bioequivalence. Tingling and itching were significantly more common after lower (<2 mA) than higher (≥3 mA) amplitude active sessions, while skin redness was significantly more common after higher amplitudes. Blinding was effective at the participant and study team levels.
HD-tDCS was well tolerated with center electrode amplitudes up to 4 mA. The bimodal ramp-up/down format of the sham was effective for blinding. These results support higher scalp-based amplitudes that enable greater brain-based current intensities in older adults.
很少有研究调查过 2 毫安(mA)以上强度的高清晰度经颅直流电刺激(HD-tDCS)的耐受性、盲法和双盲法。
我们检查了 a)HD-tDCS 在刺激过程中的耐受性,b)参与者和研究团队成员的盲法和双盲法。
将来自 292 名年龄较大的混合神经样本的数据从 3046 次 HD-tDCS 治疗中汇总(2329 次为真刺激;717 次为假刺激)。每个电极的电流强度为 1 mA 至 4 mA,总电流最高可达 10 mA。参与者在每次治疗后完成标准化的感觉(耐受性)问卷。在各种治疗结束时,参与者和研究团队成员表示参与者接受了真刺激还是假刺激。由于阳性反应率低,数据汇总为是否出现症状,并对差异和生物等效性进行了分析。
没有与安全相关的不良事件。HD-tDCS 耐受性良好,大多数治疗过程中报告的感觉为“无”或“轻度”,无论刺激条件为真刺激还是假刺激,在刺激经验丰富的参与者和刺激经验缺乏的参与者中均如此。真刺激和假刺激之间的副作用无显著差异,有些达到了生物等效性。在较低(<2 mA)强度的真刺激后,刺痛和瘙痒更为常见,而在较高强度(≥3 mA)的真刺激后,皮肤发红更为常见。参与者和研究团队层面的盲法均有效。
HD-tDCS 在中心电极强度高达 4 mA 时具有良好的耐受性。假刺激的双模态斜坡上升/下降格式对于盲法有效。这些结果支持在年龄较大的人群中使用更高的头皮强度,从而实现更大的基于大脑的电流强度。