Welch C E, Rodkey G V, von Ryll Gryska P
Ann Surg. 1986 Oct;204(4):454-67. doi: 10.1097/00000658-198610000-00014.
A retrospective study of 1068 patients who had operations for peptic ulcer disease in the 12-year period from January 1, 1974, to January 1, 1986, permits these conclusions: The number of patients admitted to the Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) has declined steadily in the years of this study--1974-1986. The average number of patients admitted with a diagnosis of peptic ulcer disease in precimetidine years--1974, 1975, and 1976--and in recent years--1982, 1983, and 1984--shows a decline of 39.3% in admissions. In the same periods, the average number of operations per year has declined from 92 in precimetidine years to an average of 71 (16.5%) recently. The decline has been greatest in patients operated on electively for duodenal ulcer. Operations for massive hemorrhage and acute perforations and the number of deaths have remained nearly constant. The overall mortality rate was 10.3%. The mortality following elective operations for pain was 0.5%; for urgent operations, including those for obstruction, 4.5%, and for bleeding other than massive, 7.5%; and for emergency operations, including those for acute perforation, 20.9%, and for massive hemorrhage, 22.1%. The main causes of death were organ failure (most commonly of the lungs) and sepsis. Early complications were documented 345 times and were followed by reoperation in 84 cases, or 7.4% of the total. Delayed stomal function was noted in 63 cases and required reoperation in 14. It was most common after Roux anastomoses and required operative intervention most commonly after gastric resection, Billroth I (GRBI). Delay was three times as common when vagotomy (V) was added to GR. Early postoperative hemorrhage was a serious complication when it occurred after operations for acute perforations or massive hemorrhage. The incidence was 3.7% after suture of a perforation; after operations for acute massive hemorrhage, it was 4.3% after pyloroplasty and vagotomy, with or without arterial ligation [PV(L)], and 0.3% after GR, with or without arterial ligation [GR(L)]. Late complications led to reoperation in 66 cases (6.2%). The most important were recurrent ulceration and alkaline gastritis. Recurrence rates after a minimum follow-up of 5 years (based on survivors of initial procedures and a second operation, both in the MGH) were 20.5% after suture of a perforation, 6.2% after PV, 2.3% after GRBII, and 0.4% after GRVBII. These figures are lower than expected; incomplete follow-up and improved medical care are factors.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
一项对1974年1月1日至1986年1月1日这12年间因消化性溃疡疾病接受手术的1068例患者的回顾性研究得出了以下结论:在本研究期间(1974 - 1986年),麻省总医院(MGH)收治的患者数量稳步下降。在西咪替丁应用前的年份(1974年、1975年和1976年)以及近年来(1982年、1983年和1984年),诊断为消化性溃疡疾病的入院患者平均数量显示入院人数下降了39.3%。在同一时期,每年的平均手术数量从西咪替丁应用前的年份的92例下降到最近的平均71例(下降了16.5%)。择期十二指肠溃疡手术患者的下降幅度最大。大量出血、急性穿孔手术以及死亡人数几乎保持不变。总体死亡率为10.3%。择期疼痛手术的死亡率为0.5%;急诊手术(包括梗阻手术)的死亡率为4.5%,非大量出血手术的死亡率为7.5%;急诊手术(包括急性穿孔手术)的死亡率为20.9%,大量出血手术的死亡率为22.1%。主要死亡原因是器官衰竭(最常见的是肺部)和败血症。记录到早期并发症345次,其中84例(占总数的7.4%)随后进行了再次手术。63例出现延迟的吻合口功能,其中14例需要再次手术。这种情况在Roux吻合术后最常见,在胃切除术毕Ⅰ式(GRBI)后最常需要手术干预。当迷走神经切断术(V)与GR联合应用时,延迟发生率是原来的三倍。急性穿孔或大量出血手术后发生的早期术后出血是一种严重并发症。穿孔缝合后的发生率为3.7%;急性大量出血手术后,幽门成形术加迷走神经切断术(无论是否行动脉结扎[PV(L)])后的发生率为4.3%,GR(无论是否行动脉结扎[GR(L)])后的发生率为0.3%。晚期并发症导致66例(6.2%)患者再次手术。最重要的是复发性溃疡和碱性胃炎。在至少随访5年(基于MGH初始手术和二次手术的幸存者)后,穿孔缝合后的复发率为20.5%,PV术后为6.2%,毕Ⅱ式胃切除术后为2.3%,胃迷走神经切断术毕Ⅱ式术后为0.4%。这些数字低于预期;随访不完全和医疗护理改善是影响因素。(摘要截选至400字)