Département de Médecine sociale et préventive (Programmes de bioéthiques), École de santé publique, Université de Montréal, Montréal, QC, Canada.
Département de Gestion, d'évaluation et de politique de santé, École de santé publique, Université de Montréal, Montréal, QC, Canada.
Eval Rev. 2024 Aug;48(4):736-765. doi: 10.1177/0193841X231198706. Epub 2023 Sep 8.
Successfully designing and implementing a program is complex; it requires a reflexive balance between the available resources and the priorities of various stakeholders, both of which change over time. Logic models are theory-based evaluation approaches used to identify and address key challenges of a program. This article describes the process of building a logic model on advanced theories in complexity studies. The models aim to support a province-wide multispecies monitoring system of antimicrobial use (AMU), designed in collaboration with the animal health sector in Quebec (Canada). Based on a rigorous theoretical foundation, the logic model is built in three steps: (1) , a narrative review of literature on similar programs in other jurisdictions; (2) iterative consultations with project members to elaborate the logic model; (3) , hypotheses based on the logic model. The model emerges from the reflexive balancing of current scientific knowledge and empirical insights to gather relevant information about stakeholders from interdisciplinary experts that led a 3-year consensus-building process within the community. Recognizing the challenge of unpacking theories for practical use, we illustrate how the process of an "open" logic model building could enable governance coordination in complex processes. Logic models are useful for evaluating public, private, and academic partnerships in One Health programs that characterize an adaptive governance process.
成功设计和实施一个项目是复杂的;它需要在可用资源和各利益攸关方的优先事项之间进行反思性平衡,而这两者都随时间而变化。逻辑模型是基于理论的评估方法,用于确定和解决项目的关键挑战。本文描述了基于复杂性研究先进理论构建逻辑模型的过程。这些模型旨在为安大略省(加拿大)与动物健康部门合作设计的抗微生物药物使用(AMU)多物种监测系统提供支持。基于严格的理论基础,逻辑模型分三个步骤构建:(1) 对其他司法管辖区类似项目的文献进行叙述性回顾;(2) 与项目成员进行反复磋商,以详细阐述逻辑模型;(3) 根据逻辑模型提出假设。该模型源自对当前科学知识和经验见解的反思性平衡,以从跨学科专家那里收集有关利益攸关方的相关信息,这些专家在社区内领导了为期 3 年的共识建立过程。认识到为实际用途阐明理论的挑战,我们说明了“开放”逻辑模型构建过程如何能够在复杂过程中实现治理协调。逻辑模型可用于评估公共、私营和学术伙伴关系在适应治理过程的“同一健康”计划中的作用。