Mansel R E, Horgan K, Webster D J, Shrotria S, Hughes L E
Br J Surg. 1986 Oct;73(10):813-6. doi: 10.1002/bjs.1800731018.
We reviewed 95 patients who underwent immediate breast reconstruction at the time of mastectomy at least one year after operation for assessment of cosmetic results and complications. There were 45 rectus abdominis and 38 latissimus dorsi myocutaneous flaps used for reconstruction. Twelve patients had subpectoral implants without a flap. The results show a remarkable concordance of assessment by patient and surgeon: both found simple subpectoral prosthesis insertion to be inferior to flap reconstruction. Flap reconstruction gave satisfactory results in the majority of patients; latissimus dorsi and rectus abdominis flaps gave similar cosmetic results. However rectus abdominis flaps showed a higher complication rate of flap necrosis and incisional hernia of the abdominal wound. Psychological assessment showed no differences between the three types of reconstruction. We conclude that immediate breast reconstruction can give excellent cosmetic results, and provides an acceptable and safe means of ameliorating the effects of mastectomy. The number of grossly unsatisfactory results decreased notably as the series progressed. Experience and meticulous attention to detail are necessary, since many patients are unwilling to have revisionary procedures if the initial result is unsatisfactory.
我们回顾了95例在乳房切除术后即刻进行乳房重建的患者,术后至少随访一年,以评估美容效果和并发症情况。其中45例采用腹直肌肌皮瓣,38例采用背阔肌肌皮瓣进行重建。12例患者采用胸大肌下植入假体而未使用皮瓣。结果显示患者和外科医生的评估结果具有显著一致性:二者均发现单纯胸大肌下假体植入术的效果不如皮瓣重建术。在大多数患者中,皮瓣重建术取得了满意的效果;背阔肌瓣和腹直肌瓣的美容效果相似。然而,腹直肌瓣出现皮瓣坏死和腹部伤口切口疝的并发症发生率较高。心理评估显示,三种重建方式之间没有差异。我们得出结论,即刻乳房重建术可获得出色的美容效果,并为改善乳房切除术的影响提供了一种可接受且安全的方法。随着病例数的增加,总体效果差的病例数显著减少。经验和对细节的精心关注是必要的,因为如果初始效果不理想,许多患者不愿意接受修复手术。